Spielberg Nathan A, Brown Matthew, Kapania Nitin R, Kegelman John C, Gerdes J Christian
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Stanford University, Building 530, 440 Escondido Mall, Stanford, CA 94305, USA.
Sci Robot. 2019 Mar 27;4(28). doi: 10.1126/scirobotics.aaw1975.
Automated vehicles navigate through their environment by first planning and subsequently following a safe trajectory. To prove safer than human beings, they must ultimately perform these tasks as well or better than human drivers across a broad range of conditions and in critical situations. We show that a feedforward-feedback control structure incorporating a simple physics-based model can be used to track a path up to the friction limits of the vehicle with performance comparable with a champion amateur race car driver. The key is having the appropriate model. Although physics-based models are useful in their transparency and intuition, they require explicit characterization around a single operating point and fail to make use of the wealth of vehicle data generated by autonomous vehicles. To circumvent these limitations, we propose a neural network structure using a sequence of past states and inputs motivated by the physical model. The neural network achieved better performance than the physical model when implemented in the same feedforward-feedback control architecture on an experimental vehicle. More notably, when trained on a combination of data from dry roads and snow, the model was able to make appropriate predictions for the road surface on which the vehicle was traveling without the need for explicit road friction estimation. These findings suggest that the network structure merits further investigation as the basis for model-based control of automated vehicles over their full operating range.
自动驾驶车辆通过首先规划并随后遵循安全轨迹在其环境中导航。为了证明比人类更安全,它们最终必须在广泛的条件下以及在关键情况下,至少能与人类驾驶员一样好地执行这些任务。我们表明,一种结合了简单物理模型的前馈-反馈控制结构可用于在达到车辆摩擦极限的情况下跟踪路径,其性能与顶级业余赛车手相当。关键在于拥有合适的模型。虽然基于物理的模型在透明度和直观性方面很有用,但它们需要围绕单个工作点进行明确的特性描述,并且未能利用自动驾驶车辆生成的大量数据。为了克服这些限制,我们提出了一种神经网络结构,该结构使用由物理模型驱动的过去状态和输入序列。当在实验车辆上以相同的前馈-反馈控制架构实现时,神经网络的性能优于物理模型。更值得注意的是,当在干燥路面和雪地的数据组合上进行训练时,该模型能够对车辆行驶的路面做出适当预测,而无需明确估计路面摩擦力。这些发现表明,作为自动驾驶车辆在其整个运行范围内基于模型控制的基础,该网络结构值得进一步研究。