Institute for Maternal and Child Health, IRCCS "Burlo Garofolo", Trieste, Italy.
Local Health Unit N. 2 "Marca Trevigiana", Public Health Department, Via Castellana 2, 31100, Treviso, Italy.
Sci Rep. 2020 Nov 6;10(1):19238. doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-74161-2.
Since Italy has the highest cesarean section (CS) rate (38.1%) among all European countries, the containment of health care costs associated with CS is needed, along with control of length of hospital stay (LOS) following CS. This population based cross-sectional study aims to investigate LoS post CS (overall CS, OCS; planned CS, PCS; urgent/emergency CS, UCS), in Friuli Venezia Giulia (a region of North-Eastern Italy) during 2005-2015, adjusting for a considerable number factors, including various obstetric conditions/complications. Maternal and newborn characteristics (health care setting and timeframe; maternal health factors; child's size factors; child's fragility factors; socio-demographic background; obstetric history; obstetric conditions) were used as independent variables. LoS (post OCS, PCS, UCS) was the outcome measure. The statistical analysis was conducted with multivariable linear (LoS expressed as adjusted mean, in days) as well as logistic (adjusted proportion of LoS > 4 days vs. LoS ≤ 4 days, using a 4 day cutoff for early discharge, ED) regression. An important decreasing trend over time in mean LoS and LoS > ED was observed for both PCS and UCS. LoS post CS was shorter with parity and history of CS, whereas it was longer among non-EU mothers. Several obstetric conditions/complications were associated with extended LoS. Whilst eclampsia/pre-eclampsia and preterm gestations (33-36 weeks) were predominantly associated with longer LoS post UCS, for PCS LoS was significantly longer with birthweight 2.0-2.5 kg, multiple birth and increasing maternal age. Strong significant inter-hospital variation remained after adjustment for the major clinical conditions. This study shows that routinely collected administrative data provide useful information for health planning and monitoring, identifying inter-hospital differences that could be targeted by policy interventions aimed at improving the efficiency of obstetric care. The important decreasing trend over time of LoS post CS, coupled with the impact of some socio-demographic and obstetric history factors on LoS, seemingly suggests a positive approach of health care providers of FVG in decision making on hospitalization length post CS. However, the significant role of several obstetric conditions did not influence hospital variation. Inter-hospital variations of LoS could depend on a number of factors, including the capacity to discharge patients into the surrounding non-acute facilities. Further studies are warranted to ascertain whether LoS can be attributed to hospital efficiency rather than the characteristics of the hospital catchment area.
由于意大利的剖宫产率(CS)在所有欧洲国家中最高(38.1%),因此需要控制与 CS 相关的医疗保健成本,并控制 CS 后的住院时间(LOS)。本基于人群的横断面研究旨在调查 2005 年至 2015 年在弗留利-威尼斯朱利亚(意大利东北部的一个地区)进行的 CS 后 LOS(总 CS、OCS;计划性 CS、PCS;紧急/紧急 CS、UCS),同时调整了相当多的因素,包括各种产科情况/并发症。产妇和新生儿特征(医疗保健环境和时间范围;产妇健康因素;儿童大小因素;儿童脆弱性因素;社会人口统计学背景;产科史;产科情况)被用作自变量。LOS(OCS、PCS、UCS 后)是结果测量指标。使用多变量线性(LOS 表示为调整后的平均值,以天数表示)和逻辑(使用 4 天截止值进行早期出院(ED)的调整后的 LOS>4 天与 LOS≤4 天的比例)回归进行统计分析。在 PCS 和 UCS 中,观察到平均 LOS 和 LOS>ED 的重要时间趋势下降。CS 后的 LOS 随产次和 CS 史而缩短,而非欧盟母亲的 LOS 则较长。一些产科情况/并发症与延长 LOS 有关。虽然子痫前期/子痫和早产(33-36 周)主要与 UCS 后较长的 LOS 相关,但 PCS 的 LOS 显著延长,与出生体重 2.0-2.5kg、多胎和产妇年龄增加有关。在调整主要临床情况后,仍存在强烈的医院间差异。本研究表明,常规收集的行政数据为卫生规划和监测提供了有用的信息,确定了医院间的差异,这些差异可能成为旨在提高产科护理效率的政策干预措施的目标。CS 后 LOS 随时间的重要下降趋势,加上一些社会人口统计学和产科史因素对 LOS 的影响,似乎表明弗留利-威尼斯朱利亚的医疗保健提供者在 CS 后住院时间决策方面采取了积极的方法。然而,一些产科情况的重要作用并没有影响医院间的差异。LOS 的医院间差异可能取决于许多因素,包括将患者出院到周围非急性设施的能力。需要进一步研究以确定 LOS 是否可以归因于医院效率,而不是医院服务区域的特征。