Moazzam Saira, Onstad Lynn, O'Leary Heather, Marshall Ariela, Osunkwo Ifeyinwa, Du Emily, Dunn Tamara, Dunlap Julianne, Reed Bill, Luger Selina, Lee Stephanie J
Clinical Research Division, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, Seattle, WA.
Division of Hematology/Oncology, Indiana University, Indianapolis, IN.
Blood Adv. 2020 Nov 10;4(21):5473-5479. doi: 10.1182/bloodadvances.2020002714.
Attendance at professional conferences is an important component of career development, because conferences are a major forum for presenting new research, interacting with colleagues and networking. An extensive literature documents differences in the professional experiences of women and men, including experiences at professional conferences. We hypothesized that women are less likely than men to ask questions at conferences, thus forgoing opportunities for professional development. To address this issue, we analyzed the question-asking behavior of women and men at the 2019 Annual Meeting and Exposition of the American Society of Hematology. In all, 112 sessions (55% of those eligible) were randomly chosen for coding, yielding data on 577 presentations. Although approximately 50% of moderators and speakers were women, the proportion of questions asked by women was significantly lower compared with the estimated proportion of women attending the conference (23% vs 39%; P < .0001). Women were more likely to ask questions if another woman asked the first question or if the session topic was red cells. These results suggest that although women are represented equally as moderators and speakers, they are less likely to engage in the postpresentation discourse by asking questions. Encouraging women to speak up in professional situations and providing training on question-asking skills can help address this gender gap that potentially contributes to disparities in professional visibility and career advancement for women in hematology.
参加专业会议是职业发展的重要组成部分,因为会议是展示新研究、与同事互动和建立人际关系的主要平台。大量文献记录了女性和男性在职业经历上的差异,包括在专业会议上的经历。我们假设,在会议上女性比男性提问的可能性更小,从而错失职业发展机会。为解决这一问题,我们分析了2019年美国血液学会年会暨博览会上女性和男性的提问行为。总共随机选择了112场会议(占符合条件会议的55%)进行编码,得到了577场报告的数据。尽管大约50%的主持人和发言人是女性,但与参会女性的估计比例相比,女性提问的比例显著更低(23%对39%;P < 0.0001)。如果有另一位女性首先提问或者会议主题是红细胞,女性更有可能提问。这些结果表明,尽管女性作为主持人和发言人的比例相同,但她们通过提问参与会后讨论的可能性更小。鼓励女性在专业场合发言并提供提问技巧培训有助于解决这一性别差距,这一差距可能导致血液学领域女性在职业知名度和职业晋升方面存在差异。