Goyal Tarun, Singh Gaganpreet, Kumar Tripathy Sujit, Schuh Alexander, Veerappa Lokesh A, Kumar Sen Ramesh
Department of Orthopaedics, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Bathinda, Punjab, 151001, India.
Department of Orthopaedics, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Bhubaneswar, Odisha, 751019, India.
J Clin Orthop Trauma. 2020 Nov-Dec;11(6):989-1001. doi: 10.1016/j.jcot.2020.09.008. Epub 2020 Sep 12.
Acetabulum fractures are being increasingly seen with low impact injuries in elderly patients. This article aimed to study systematically literature on geriatric acetabulum fractures. Objectives of this systematic review were to study (1) demography of patients, common mechanisms of injury and types of fracture patterns commonly seen in elderly patients, (2) treatment used for these fractures in literature and (3) mortality rates in elderly with these fractures.
Systematic search was carried out in May 2020 using predefined search strategy for all studies published in the English language in last 20 years. Literature search and data abstraction was done by two independent reviewers.
After screening of all abstracts, a total of 48 studies were included in the systematic review. In total there were 7876 geriatric patients with acetabulum fractures. Mean age of the patients was 72.47 years. There were 4841 males (61.5%). Fall from low heights was the most common mechanism of injury, present in 47.12% patients followed by motor vehicular accidents in 28.73%. Most common fracture pattern was both column fracture, seen in 19.03% patients, followed by anterior column and posterior hemitransverse fracture in 17.23%, anterior column fractures in 17.13%, and posterior wall fractures in 13.46% patients. Out of total 5160 patients for whom details of treatment were available, 2199 (42.62%) were given non-operative treatment, 2285 (44.28%) were treated with ORIF of acetabulum fracture, 161 (3.12%) were treated with percutaneous fixation and 515 (9.98%) were treated with primary THA. Gull sign, femoral head injury and posterior wall comminution were associated with poorer prognosis after ORIF and may form an indication for a primary THA.
Literature on treatment of geriatric acetabulum fractures is not enough to draw any definite conclusions. There is limited evidence from current literature that surgery could be considered a safe treatment option for displaced acetabulum fractures in elderly. Primary THA can provide early mobility and reduce chances of resurgery in fracture patterns where restoration of joint surface may not be possible.
老年患者因低冲击力损伤导致髋臼骨折的情况日益增多。本文旨在系统研究老年髋臼骨折的相关文献。本系统评价的目的是研究:(1)患者的人口统计学特征、常见损伤机制以及老年患者中常见的骨折类型;(2)文献中针对这些骨折所采用的治疗方法;(3)患有这些骨折的老年患者的死亡率。
2020年5月,采用预定义的搜索策略,对过去20年以英文发表的所有研究进行系统检索。文献检索和数据提取由两名独立的评审员完成。
在筛选了所有摘要后,共有48项研究纳入该系统评价。总共有7876例老年髋臼骨折患者。患者的平均年龄为72.47岁。男性有4841例(61.5%)。从低处跌落是最常见的损伤机制,占47.12%的患者,其次是机动车事故,占28.73%。最常见的骨折类型是双柱骨折,见于19.03%的患者,其次是前柱和后半横行骨折,占17.23%,前柱骨折占17.13%,后壁骨折占13.46%的患者。在总共5160例有治疗细节的患者中,2199例(42.62%)接受了非手术治疗,2285例(44.28%)接受了髋臼骨折切开复位内固定术(ORIF),161例(3.12%)接受了经皮固定,515例(9.98%)接受了一期全髋关节置换术(THA)。海鸥征、股骨头损伤和后壁粉碎与ORIF术后预后较差相关,可能是一期THA的指征。
关于老年髋臼骨折治疗的文献不足以得出任何明确结论。目前文献中的证据有限,表明手术可被视为老年移位髋臼骨折的一种安全治疗选择。一期THA可提供早期活动能力,并减少在无法恢复关节面的骨折类型中再次手术的机会。