Phen Huai Ming, Wise Brent, Thompson Daniel, Nascone Jason, Boissonneault Adam, Maceroli Michael
Emory Orthopaedics and Spine Center, 59 Executive Park S, Atlanta, GA, 30329, USA.
J Clin Orthop Trauma. 2020 Nov-Dec;11(6):1151-1157. doi: 10.1016/j.jcot.2020.10.035. Epub 2020 Oct 19.
The purpose of this study is to compare biomechanical properties of fully and partially threaded iliosacral screws. We hypothesise that fully threaded screws will have a higher yield force, and less deformation than partially threaded screws following axial loading. Twenty sawbone blocks were uniformly divided to simulate vertical sacral fractures. Ten blocks were affixed with fully threaded iliosacral screws in an over-drilled, lag-by-technique fashion whilst the remaining ten were fixed with partially threaded lag-by-design screws. All screws measured 7.3-mm x 145 mm, and were inserted to a 70% of calculated maximal insertional torque, ensuring uniform screw placement throughout across models. Continuous axial loads were applied to 3 constructs of each type to failure to determine baseline characteristics. Five hundred loading cycles of 500 N at 1 Hz were applied to 4 constructs of each type, and then axially loaded to failure. Force displacement curves, elastic, and plastic deformation of each construct was recorded. Fully threaded constructs had a 428% higher yield force, 61% higher stiffness, 125% higher ultimate force, and 66% lower yield deformation (p < 0.05). The average plastic deformation for partially threaded constructs was 336% higher than fully threaded constructs (p = 0.071), the final elastic deflection was 10% higher (p = 0.248), and the average total movement was 21% higher (p = 0.107). We conclude from this biomechanical study that fully threaded, lag-by-technique iliosacral screws can withstand significantly higher axial loads to failure than partially threaded screws. In addition, fully threaded screws trended towards exhibiting a significantly lower plastic deformation following cyclical loading.
本研究的目的是比较全螺纹和部分螺纹髂骶螺钉的生物力学性能。我们假设,在轴向加载后,全螺纹螺钉将具有更高的屈服力,且变形比部分螺纹螺钉更小。将20个尸体骨块均匀分割以模拟垂直骶骨骨折。10个骨块以钻孔后置技术方式用全螺纹髂骶螺钉固定,而其余10个则用部分螺纹的设计后置螺钉固定。所有螺钉尺寸均为7.3毫米×145毫米,并以计算出的最大插入扭矩的70%插入,确保在所有模型中螺钉放置均匀。对每种类型的3个结构施加连续轴向载荷直至破坏,以确定基线特征。对每种类型的4个结构施加500 N、1 Hz的500次加载循环,然后轴向加载直至破坏。记录每个结构的力-位移曲线、弹性和塑性变形。全螺纹结构的屈服力高428%,刚度高61%,极限力高125%,屈服变形低66%(p<0.05)。部分螺纹结构的平均塑性变形比全螺纹结构高336%(p = 0.071),最终弹性挠度高10%(p = 0.248),平均总位移高21%(p = 0.107)。我们从这项生物力学研究得出结论,全螺纹、钻孔后置技术的髂骶螺钉在轴向加载至破坏时能承受比部分螺纹螺钉显著更高的载荷。此外,全螺纹螺钉在循环加载后有呈现出显著更低塑性变形的趋势。