Jeyakumar Jenaniy, Sculean Anton, Eick Sigrun
Oral Health Prev Dent. 2020 Oct 27;18(4):981-990. doi: 10.3290/j.ohpd.a45437.
To analyze in vitro new formulations with Citrox and chlorhexidine digluconate (CHX) regarding their antibacterial activity against planktonic bacteria and their potential to inhibit biofilm formation or to act on existing biofilms.
Five oral health care products with 0.05%-0.5% CHX formulations (four rinses and one gel) were compared with Citrox preparations and additive-free CHX solutions. The minimal inhibitory concentrations (MIC) were determined against 13 oral bacteria associated with caries or periodontitis. Further, the activity on retarding biofilm formation and on existing biofilms was analyzed; both a 'cariogenic' (5 species) and a 'periodontal' (12 species) biofilm were included.
The MIC values did not differ between the CHX mouthrinse/gel formulations and the respective additive-free CHX solutions. Citrox was active against selected periodontopathogens (e.g. Porphyromonas gingivalis). The CHX formulations more effectively retarded biofilm formation than did solutions with the same concentration of CHX but without additives. The anti-biofilm activities depended on the CHX concentration in the formulations. Both CHX solutions and formulations (rinse and gel) were only slightly active on an already formed biofilm. Citrox did not exert any anti-biofilm effect.
The present in vitro data support the anti-biofilm activity of the novel CHX, Citrox, poly-L-lysine and xylitol oral health-care formulations. Further studies are warranted to confirm the present findings in various clinical settings.
分析含有西曲溴铵(Citrox)和葡萄糖酸氯己定(CHX)的新型体外制剂对浮游细菌的抗菌活性,以及它们抑制生物膜形成或作用于现有生物膜的潜力。
将五种含0.05%-0.5% CHX制剂的口腔护理产品(四种漱口水和一种凝胶)与西曲溴铵制剂及无添加剂的CHX溶液进行比较。测定了对13种与龋齿或牙周炎相关的口腔细菌的最低抑菌浓度(MIC)。此外,分析了其对生物膜形成的抑制作用以及对现有生物膜的作用;包括一种“致龋性”(5种菌)生物膜和一种“牙周性”(12种菌)生物膜。
CHX漱口水/凝胶制剂与相应的无添加剂CHX溶液的MIC值无差异。西曲溴铵对某些牙周病原体(如牙龈卟啉单胞菌)有活性。CHX制剂比相同浓度但无添加剂的溶液更有效地抑制生物膜形成。抗生物膜活性取决于制剂中CHX的浓度。CHX溶液和制剂(漱口水和凝胶)对已形成的生物膜只有轻微活性。西曲溴铵没有发挥任何抗生物膜作用。
目前的体外数据支持新型CHX、西曲溴铵、聚-L-赖氨酸和木糖醇口腔护理制剂的抗生物膜活性。需要进一步研究以在各种临床环境中证实目前的发现。