People's Hospital of the Tibet Autonomous Region, Lhasa, 850000, China.
Internal Medicine Branch of Cadiovascular Diseases/Plateau Medicine, People's Hospital of Tibet Autonomous Region, Lhasa, 850000, China.
Cardiovasc Drugs Ther. 2022 Feb;36(1):103-112. doi: 10.1007/s10557-020-07110-w. Epub 2020 Nov 23.
Although the use of direct oral anticoagulants (DOACs) has been reported in patients with atrial fibrillation (AF), there is currently no consensus on the occurrence or characteristics of the hemorrhage risk in different antithrombotic regimens.
Disproportionality and Bayesian analyses were performed in mining data of suspected hemorrhagic events after antithrombotic drug use from the FDA Adverse Event Reporting System (FAERS) from January 2004 to September 2019. The time to onset and fatality rate of hemorrhage following different antithrombotic regimens were also compared.
A total of 84,998 reports of hemorrhage-related adverse events with the use of antithrombotic drugs were identified. The patients included were mostly from the Americas (80.87%) and Europe (13.22%), with most data submitted by nonhealthcare professionals. Among the seven antithrombotic drug monotherapies, betrixaban had the highest association with hemorrhage based on the highest reporting odds ratio (ROR, 829.95; 95% CI = 113.61-6063.15), proportional reporting ratio (PRR, 24.68, χ2 = 804.24), and multi-item gamma Poisson shrinker (MGPS, 24.68, 95% one-sided CI = 4.67). The combination therapies of clopidogrel plus new oral anticoagulants had higher RORs, PRRs, and empirical Bayesian geometric means (EBGMs) than the antithrombotic drug monotherapies. Hemorrhage associated with rivaroxaban plus clopidogrel appeared to have an earlier onset (171 days vs 219 days, 95% two-sided CI =68.68-27.34, p < 0.0001) and a lower fatality rate (15.30% vs 17.74%, p<0.05) than that associated with rivaroxaban monotherapy.
This study provides a relevant overview of the hemorrhagic complications/fatalities associated with different antithrombotic regimens in their real-world use. Among the combination therapies, clopidogrel plus DOACs were found to have stronger associations with hemorrhage than traditional dual antithrombotic therapies. Rivaroxaban showed a stronger association with hemorrhage than other antithrombotic drug monotherapies, and apixaban monotherapy appeared to have weaker associations with hemorrhage than others.
尽管已有使用直接口服抗凝剂(DOAC)治疗心房颤动(AF)的报道,但目前对于不同抗栓方案的出血风险发生或特征尚无共识。
通过挖掘 2004 年 1 月至 2019 年 9 月 FDA 不良事件报告系统(FAERS)中抗血栓药物使用后疑似出血事件的数据,进行比例失衡和贝叶斯分析。还比较了不同抗栓方案后出血的发病时间和死亡率。
共确定了 84998 例与抗血栓药物相关的出血不良事件报告。患者主要来自美洲(80.87%)和欧洲(13.22%),大部分数据由非卫生保健专业人员提交。在七种抗血栓药物单药治疗中,依度沙班的报告比值比(ROR)最高(829.95;95%置信区间[CI] = 113.61-6063.15)、比例报告比(PRR)最高(24.68,χ2 = 804.24)和多项伽马泊松收缩(MGPS)最高(24.68,95%单侧 CI = 4.67),与出血关联最高。氯吡格雷联合新型口服抗凝剂的联合治疗方案的 ROR、PRR 和经验贝叶斯几何均数(EBGM)均高于抗血栓药物单药治疗。与利伐沙班单药治疗相比,利伐沙班联合氯吡格雷与出血相关的发病时间更早(171 天 vs 219 天,95%双侧 CI=68.68-27.34,p < 0.0001),死亡率更低(15.30% vs 17.74%,p<0.05)。
本研究提供了真实世界应用中不同抗栓方案出血并发症/死亡率的相关概述。在联合治疗方案中,氯吡格雷联合 DOAC 与出血的相关性强于传统双联抗栓治疗。与其他抗血栓药物单药治疗相比,利伐沙班与出血的相关性更强,阿哌沙班单药治疗与出血的相关性似乎较弱。