Chiva-Bartoll Oscar, Baena-Extremera Antonio, Hortiguela-Alcalá David, Ruiz-Montero Pedro Jesús
Department of Education and Specific Didactics, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Universitat Jaume I, 12071 Castellón, Spain.
Department of Education Sciences, Faculty of Education, University of Granada, University Campus of Cartuja, s/n, 18071 Granada, Spain.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020 Nov 25;17(23):8756. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17238756.
Service-learning (SL) is a pedagogical model focused on achieving curricular goals while providing a community service. Previous research suggests that SL might promote qualities such as self-esteem, motivation, problem-focused coping, decision-making, empathy, and communication, which are associated with a psychological construct known as students' Effective Personality (EP). These studies, however, did not specifically analyse the direct effects of SL on this construct. The aim of this study is to explicitly analyse the effect of SL on Physical Education Teacher Education (PETE) students' EP using a mixed methods approach. The quantitative part of the approach followed a quasi-experimental design using the validated "Effective Personality Questionnaire for University Students", which includes four dimensions: "Academic self-efficacy", "Social self-realisation", "Self-esteem", and "Resolutive self-efficacy". A non-probabilistic sampling on a total of 181 PETE students was then carried out, with 98 participating in the experimental group (42 male, 56 female), and 83 in the control group (34 male, 49 female). The comparisons revealed significant improvements in the experimental group, especially in the social self-realisation and resolutive self-efficacy dimensions. These findings were complemented by a qualitative analysis of 12 students' semi-structured interviews. In conclusion, the study reported a positive influence of SL on the PETE students' EP, providing valuable design patterns for future SL implementations.
服务学习(SL)是一种教学模式,专注于在提供社区服务的同时实现课程目标。先前的研究表明,服务学习可能会促进诸如自尊、动机、以问题为中心的应对、决策、同理心和沟通等品质,这些品质与一种被称为学生有效人格(EP)的心理结构相关。然而,这些研究并没有具体分析服务学习对这一结构的直接影响。本研究的目的是使用混合方法明确分析服务学习对体育教师教育(PETE)专业学生有效人格的影响。该方法的定量部分采用准实验设计,使用经过验证的“大学生有效人格问卷”,该问卷包括四个维度:“学业自我效能感”、“社会自我实现”、“自尊”和“解决问题的自我效能感”。然后对总共181名体育教师教育专业学生进行了非概率抽样,其中98人参与实验组(42名男性,56名女性),83人参与对照组(34名男性,49名女性)。比较结果显示实验组有显著改善,尤其是在社会自我实现和解决问题的自我效能感维度。对12名学生的半结构化访谈进行的定性分析补充了这些发现。总之,该研究报告了服务学习对体育教师教育专业学生有效人格有积极影响,为未来服务学习的实施提供了有价值的设计模式。