Bae Sungwoo, Choi Hongyoon, Whi Wonseok, Paeng Jin Chul, Cheon Gi Jeong, Kang Keon Wook, Lee Dong Soo
Department of Nuclear Medicine, Seoul National University Hospital, 101, Daehak-ro, Jongno-gu, Seoul, 03080 Republic of Korea.
Department of Molecular Medicine and Biopharmaceutical Sciences, Graduate School of Convergence Science and Technology, Seoul National University, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Nucl Med Mol Imaging. 2020 Dec;54(6):305-314. doi: 10.1007/s13139-020-00669-0. Epub 2020 Oct 13.
The precise quantification of dopamine transporter (DAT) density on -(3-[F]Fluoropropyl)-2β-carbomethoxy-3β-(4-iodophenyl) nortropane positron emission tomography ([F]FP-CIT PET) imaging is crucial to measure the degree of striatal DAT loss in patients with parkinsonism. The quantitative analysis requires a spatial normalization process based on a template brain. Since the spatial normalization method based on a delayed-phase PET has limited performance, we suggest an early-phase PET-based method and compared its accuracy, referring to the MRI-based approach as a gold standard.
A total of 39 referred patients from the movement disorder clinic who underwent dual-phase [F]FP-CIT PET and took MRI within 1 year were retrospectively analyzed. The three spatial normalization methods were applied for quantification of [F]FP-CIT PET-MRI-based anatomical normalization, PET template-based method based on delayed PET, and that based on early PET. The striatal binding ratios (BRs) were compared, and voxelwise paired tests were implemented between different methods.
The early image-based normalization showed concordant patterns of putaminal [F]FP-CIT binding with an MRI-based method. The BRs of the putamen from the MRI-based approach showed higher agreement with early image- than delayed image-based method as presented by Bland-Altman plots and intraclass correlation coefficients (early image-based, 0.980; delayed image-based, 0.895). The voxelwise test exhibited a smaller volume of significantly different counts in putamen between brains processed by early image and MRI compared to that between delayed image and MRI.
The early-phase [F]FP-CIT PET can be utilized for spatial normalization of delayed PET image when the MRI image is unavailable and presents better performance than the delayed template-based method in quantitation of putaminal binding ratio.
在帕金森综合征患者中,精确量化多巴胺转运体(DAT)密度对于测量纹状体DAT丢失程度至关重要。定量分析需要基于模板脑的空间归一化过程。由于基于延迟期正电子发射断层扫描(PET)的空间归一化方法性能有限,我们提出了一种基于早期PET的方法,并将其准确性与基于磁共振成像(MRI)的方法(作为金标准)进行比较。
回顾性分析了39例来自运动障碍门诊的转诊患者,这些患者在1年内接受了双期[F]氟丙基-2β-甲氧基羰基-3β-(4-碘苯基)去甲托烷正电子发射断层扫描([F]FP-CIT PET)并进行了MRI检查。应用三种空间归一化方法对基于[F]FP-CIT PET-MRI的解剖归一化、基于延迟PET的PET模板法和基于早期PET的方法进行定量。比较纹状体结合率(BRs),并在不同方法之间进行体素级配对检验。
基于早期图像的归一化显示壳核[F]FP-CIT结合模式与基于MRI的方法一致。如Bland-Altman图和组内相关系数所示,基于MRI方法的壳核BRs与基于早期图像的方法比基于延迟图像的方法具有更高的一致性(基于早期图像的方法,0.980;基于延迟图像的方法,0.895)。体素级检验显示,与基于延迟图像和MRI处理的脑之间相比,基于早期图像和MRI处理的脑之间壳核中显著不同计数的体积更小。
当无法获得MRI图像时,早期[F]FP-CIT PET可用于延迟PET图像的空间归一化,并且在壳核结合率定量方面比基于延迟模板的方法表现更好。