Barbaro Josephine, Wang Chongying, Wang Jing, Liu Gongshu, Liang Ying, Wang Ji, Abdullahi Ifrah, Dissanayake Cheryl
Olga Tennison Autism Research Centre, School of Psychology and Public Health, La Trobe University, Melbourne, VIC, Australia.
Department of Social Psychology, Zhou Enlai School of Government, Nankai University, Tianjin, China.
Front Neurol. 2020 Nov 16;11:597790. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2020.597790. eCollection 2020.
Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) comprises difficulties in social communication and restrictive and repetitive behaviors. Despite an increased global prevalence, little remains known about early detection and diagnosis of autism in Mainland China. Our aim was to conduct a pilot investigation of the implementation of an Australian tool, Social Attention and Communication Surveillance (SACS), in Tianjin, China (SACS-C) by trained professionals to identify autism early compared to the Checklist for Autism in Toddlers-23 (CHAT-23) completed by parents and professionals. A total of 10,514 children were monitored across 61 Community Health Service Centres in six Tianjin districts on the SACS-C at 12, 18, and 24 months of age following a half-day training of 225 child health practitioners. Children deemed at "high likelihood" for autism on either the SACS, CHAT-23, or both, were referred for developmental assessments at the Tianjin Women and Children's Health Centre (TWCHC). A total of 87 children (0.8%) were identified at "high likelihood" on the SACS-C, of whom 57 (66%) were assessed for autism; 24 children were subsequently diagnosed with autism (42.1%), and the remaining 33 (57.9%) were diagnosed with developmental and/or language delays. The SACS-C had a positive predictive value (PPV) of 42.1%, a negative predictive value (NPV) of 99.8%, and sensitivity and specificity of 53.3 and 99.7%, respectively. Only 21 children were identified at "high risk" for autism on the CHAT-23 (0.2%), over four times fewer children than the SACS-C, with 14 children assessed for autism (66%); nine were diagnosed with autism (64.3%) and the remaining five children were diagnosed with developmental and/or language delays. The CHAT-23 had an overall PPV of 64.3%, NPV of 99.6%, sensitivity of 27.3%, and specificity of 99.9%. This was the first large-scale study identifying autism in 12-24-month-old children in China. We ascertained the feasibility of training community health practitioners to monitor infants and toddlers for the early signs of autism, and determined the effectiveness of their use of SACS-C which had a better balance between accuracy and sensitivity in detecting autism in contrast to the CHAT-23 which missed the majority of children with autism (72.7%) vs. the SACS-C (46.7%). Given the emphasis on identifying as many children with autism as possible in Mainland China, SACS-C was identified as the tool of choice by the TWCHC. However, more work is needed to improve the psychometric properties in using the SACS-C in Mainland China so that it is comparable to its use in Australia.
自闭症谱系障碍(ASD)包括社交沟通困难以及局限和重复行为。尽管全球患病率有所上升,但关于中国大陆自闭症的早期检测和诊断仍知之甚少。我们的目的是在中国天津对一种澳大利亚工具——社交注意力与沟通监测量表(SACS)的中文版(SACS-C)进行试点调查,由经过培训的专业人员使用该量表,与家长和专业人员完成的幼儿自闭症筛查量表-23项(CHAT-23)相比,更早地识别出自闭症。在对225名儿童保健从业者进行了为期半天的培训后,对天津六个区的61个社区卫生服务中心的10514名儿童在12、18和24月龄时使用SACS-C进行监测。在SACS、CHAT-23或两者上被判定为自闭症“高可能性”的儿童,被转介至天津市妇女儿童保健中心(TWCHC)进行发育评估。共有87名儿童(0.8%)在SACS-C上被判定为“高可能性”,其中57名(66%)接受了自闭症评估;随后24名儿童被诊断为自闭症(42.1%),其余33名(57.9%)被诊断为发育和/或语言迟缓。SACS-C的阳性预测值(PPV)为42.1%,阴性预测值(NPV)为99.8%,敏感性和特异性分别为53.3%和99.7%。在CHAT-23上只有21名儿童(0.2%)被判定为自闭症“高风险”,比SACS-C判定出的儿童少四倍多,其中14名儿童接受了自闭症评估(66%);9名被诊断为自闭症(64.3%),其余5名儿童被诊断为发育和/或语言迟缓。CHAT-23的总体PPV为64.3%,NPV为99.6%,敏感性为27.3%,特异性为99.9%。这是在中国对12至24月龄儿童进行自闭症识别的第一项大规模研究。我们确定了培训社区卫生从业者监测婴幼儿自闭症早期迹象的可行性,并确定了他们使用SACS-C的有效性,与CHAT-23相比,SACS-C在检测自闭症时在准确性和敏感性之间有更好的平衡,CHAT-23遗漏了大多数自闭症儿童(72.7%),而SACS-C遗漏了46.7%。鉴于中国大陆强调尽可能多地识别出自闭症儿童这一点,SACS-C被TWCHC确定为首选工具。然而,需要开展更多工作来改善SACS-C在中国大陆使用时的心理测量特性,使其与在澳大利亚的使用情况具有可比性。