Health Service Executive, Dublin, Ireland.
University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
J Health Organ Manag. 2020 Dec 18;ahead-of-print(ahead-of-print):18-33. doi: 10.1108/JHOM-02-2020-0065.
While clinical governance is assumed to be part of organisational structures and policies, implementation of clinical governance in practice (the praxis) can be markedly different. This paper draws on insights from hospital clinicians, managers and governors on how they interpret the term "clinical governance". The influence of best-practice and roles and responsibilities on their interpretations is considered.
DESIGN/METHODOLOGY/APPROACH: The research is based on 40 in-depth, semi-structured interviews with hospital clinicians, managers and governors from two large academic hospitals in Ireland. The analytical lens for the research is practice theory. Interview transcripts are analysed for practitioners' spoken keywords/terms to explore how practitioners interpret the term "clinical governance". The practice of clinical governance is mapped to front line, management and governance roles and responsibilities.
The research finds that interpretation of clinical governance in praxis is quite different from best-practice definitions. Practitioner roles and responsibilities held influence practitioners' interpretation.
ORIGINALITY/VALUE: The research examines interpretations of clinical governance in praxis by clinicians, managers and governors and highlights the adverse consequence of the absence of clear mapping of roles and responsibilities to clinical, management and governance practice.
虽然临床治理被认为是组织结构和政策的一部分,但在实践中(实践)实施临床治理可能有很大的不同。本文借鉴了医院临床医生、管理人员和主管对如何解释“临床治理”一词的见解。考虑了最佳实践以及角色和职责对其解释的影响。
设计/方法/方法:该研究基于对爱尔兰两家大型学术医院的 40 名医院临床医生、管理人员和主管的深入、半结构化访谈。研究的分析视角是实践理论。对访谈记录进行分析,以寻找从业者的口语关键词/术语,以探讨从业者如何解释“临床治理”一词。临床治理实践与一线、管理和治理角色和职责相对应。
研究发现,实践中临床治理的解释与最佳实践定义有很大不同。从业者的角色和职责的持有影响从业者的解释。
原创性/价值:本研究通过临床医生、管理人员和主管检查了对实践中临床治理的解释,并强调了明确映射角色和职责与临床、管理和治理实践之间缺乏明确映射的不利后果。