Department of Experimental Psychology, University College London, London, United Kingdom.
Department of General Psychology, University of Padova, Padova, Italy.
Psychophysiology. 2021 Mar;58(3):e13750. doi: 10.1111/psyp.13750. Epub 2020 Dec 19.
Similarity measures, the extent to which two concepts have similar meanings, are the key to understand how concepts are represented, with different theoretical perspectives relying on very different sources of data from which similarity can be calculated. While there is some commonality in similarity measures, the extent of their correlation is limited. Previous studies also suggested that the relative performance of different similarity measures may also vary depending on concept concreteness and that the inferior parietal lobule (IPL) may be involved in the integration of conceptual features in a multimodal system for the semantic categorization. Here, we tested for the first time whether theory-based similarity measures predict the pattern of brain activity in the IPL differently for abstract and concrete concepts. English speakers performed a semantic decision task, while we recorded their brain activity in IPL through fNIRS. Using representational similarity analysis, results indicated that the neural representational similarity in IPL conformed to the lexical co-occurrence among concrete concepts (regardless of the hemisphere) and to the affective similarity among abstract concepts in the left hemisphere only, implying that semantic representations of abstract and concrete concepts are characterized along different organizational principles in the IPL. We observed null results for the decoding accuracy. Our study suggests that the use of the representational similarity analysis as a complementary analysis to the decoding accuracy is a promising tool to reveal similarity patterns between theoretical models and brain activity recorded through fNIRS.
相似性度量是理解概念如何表示的关键,它是指两个概念具有相似含义的程度,不同的理论观点依赖于非常不同的数据来源,这些数据可以用来计算相似性。虽然相似性度量有一些共同之处,但它们的相关性程度有限。先前的研究还表明,不同相似性度量的相对性能也可能因概念的具体程度而异,并且下顶叶(IPL)可能参与了概念特征在多模态系统中的整合,用于语义分类。在这里,我们首次测试了基于理论的相似性度量是否会以不同的方式预测 IPL 中抽象和具体概念的大脑活动模式。讲英语的人执行语义决策任务,而我们通过功能性近红外光谱技术(fNIRS)记录他们在 IPL 中的大脑活动。使用表示相似性分析的结果表明,IPL 中的神经表示相似性与具体概念(无论半球)之间的词汇共现以及左半球中抽象概念之间的情感相似性一致,这意味着抽象和具体概念的语义表示在 IPL 中沿着不同的组织原则进行。我们没有观察到解码准确性的结果。我们的研究表明,将表示相似性分析用作解码准确性的补充分析是一种很有前途的工具,可以揭示理论模型和通过 fNIRS 记录的大脑活动之间的相似性模式。