Bowen Catherine E, Spuling Svenja M, Kornadt Anna E, Wiest Maja
Vienna, Austria.
German Centre of Gerontology (DZA), Manfred-von-Richthofen-Str. 2, 12101 Berlin, Germany.
Eur J Ageing. 2019 Dec 12;17(4):435-444. doi: 10.1007/s10433-019-00548-4. eCollection 2020 Dec.
We use questionnaire data from the MIDUS study ( = 6325 and a subsample = 2120) to examine the extent to which people in their late 20s, late 40s and late 60s think that positive characteristics apply to themselves, their age peers and other age groups. Results based on factor analysis confirmed the existence of age stereotypes, such that one constellation of characteristics (wise, caring, calm, knowledgeable, generative; "wise") was seen as more descriptive of older adults, while another constellation of characteristics (energetic, healthy, willing to learn; "energetic") was seen as more descriptive of younger adults. Self-evaluations were, however, highly positive and largely independent of age. As a group, younger adults saw themselves as being as "energetic" but "wiser" than their age peers, while older adults saw themselves as being more "energetic" but less "wise" than their age peers. In sum, the results suggest that self-views are relatively independent of existing age stereotypes but also indicate that the "better-than-average effect" depends on age and whether the considered characteristics represent a relative strength or weakness of one's own age group. The results also indicate that, at the aggregate level, older adults' tendency to use stereotypes about their age group's weaknesses as a frame of reference for making flattering self-evaluations seems to outweigh the effects of stereotype internalization.
我们使用来自美国中年发展研究(MIDUS)的问卷数据(n = 6325,子样本n = 2120),来考察20多岁后期、40多岁后期和60多岁后期的人群在多大程度上认为积极特质适用于他们自己、同龄人以及其他年龄组。基于因子分析的结果证实了年龄刻板印象的存在,即一组特质(明智、体贴、冷静、知识渊博、有创造力;“明智”)被认为更能描述老年人,而另一组特质(精力充沛、健康、愿意学习;“精力充沛”)被认为更能描述年轻人。然而,自我评估非常积极,且在很大程度上与年龄无关。总体而言,年轻人认为自己比同龄人“精力充沛”且“更明智”,而老年人则认为自己比同龄人“更精力充沛”但“更不明智”。总之,结果表明自我认知相对独立于现有的年龄刻板印象,但也表明“优于平均效应”取决于年龄以及所考虑的特质是代表自己年龄组的相对优势还是劣势。结果还表明,在总体水平上,老年人倾向于将关于自己年龄组弱点的刻板印象作为进行自夸性自我评估的参照框架,这一倾向似乎超过了刻板印象内化的影响。