Austin Tamar, Boyd Jade
British Columbia Centre on Substance Use, 400 - 1045 Howe Street, Vancouver, BC, V6Z 2A9, Canada.
Department of Medicine, University of British Columbia, St. Paul's Hospital, 608-1081 Burrard Street, Vancouver, BC, V6Z 1Y6, Canada.
Harm Reduct J. 2021 Jan 6;18(1):1. doi: 10.1186/s12954-020-00453-5.
Ongoing legal and social discrimination, and stigmatization of people with lived experience of drug use (PWLE) continues to contribute to overdose-related deaths in Canada. The involvement of PWLE working in harm reduction services has proven effective in decreasing drug-related harms among PWLE; however, there exist unintended negative impacts. PWLE working in harm reduction services risk overextending themselves beyond employment parameters (e.g., emotional labor) with few systems in place (e.g., employment advocacy) for support. While meaningful participation of PWLE in harm reduction programs is critical to addressing the overdose crisis, their labor in Canada's overdose response commands further investigation and recognition. This paper examines some of the benefits and negative aspects of working in harm reduction among PWLE.
Fifty qualitative surveys were completed by PWLE working in harm reduction services from across Canada at the National 2018 Stimulus conference held in Edmonton, Alberta. The surveys focused on the benefits and negatives of 'peer' employment and recommendations for organizational transformation through short answer written sections. Surveys were analyzed thematically using NVivo, informed by critical perspectives on substance use, with attention to key re-occurring themes on employment equity.
While participants described multiple benefits of working in harm reduction services, such as the valuing of their expertise by fellow 'peers,' growing skill sets, countering stigma, and preventing overdose deaths, issues of workplace equity were significantly identified. Stigma, tokenism, workplace discrimination, including power and pay inequities, as well as lack of worker compensation and benefits were identified as key factors persisting in the everyday experiences of participants.
Continued exposure to stigma, workplace discrimination, and/or power imbalances, combined with the impact of high stakes employment (e.g., dealing with overdose deaths), can have significant consequences for PWLE working in harm reduction, including burn out. Policy recommendations include large-scale structural changes that address inequities of hierarchical 'peer' employment for PWLE, including increased leadership roles for diverse PWLE, pay equity and benefits, unionization, as well as more supportive working environments attentive to the intersecting social-structural factors (poverty, criminalization, racism, gendered violence) impacting the everyday lives of PWLE working in harm reduction.
持续存在的法律和社会歧视,以及对有吸毒经历者(PWLE)的污名化,继续导致加拿大与药物过量相关的死亡。有吸毒经历者参与减少伤害服务已被证明在减少有吸毒经历者的药物相关伤害方面是有效的;然而,也存在一些意想不到的负面影响。在减少伤害服务领域工作的有吸毒经历者有可能超出工作范围(如情感劳动)过度劳累,而几乎没有相应的支持体系(如就业倡导)。虽然有吸毒经历者有意义地参与减少伤害项目对于应对药物过量危机至关重要,但他们在加拿大应对药物过量方面的工作需要进一步调查和认可。本文探讨了有吸毒经历者在减少伤害工作中的一些益处和负面影响。
在艾伯塔省埃德蒙顿举行的2018年全国刺激会议上,来自加拿大各地从事减少伤害服务的有吸毒经历者完成了50份定性调查问卷。这些调查通过简短的书面回答部分,聚焦于“同伴”就业的益处和弊端以及组织转型的建议。调查采用NVivo进行主题分析,以对物质使用的批判性观点为依据,关注就业公平方面反复出现的关键主题。
虽然参与者描述了在减少伤害服务工作中的多种益处,比如被同行“同伴”重视专业知识、技能不断提升、消除污名以及预防药物过量死亡,但工作场所公平问题也被显著提及。污名、装点门面、工作场所歧视,包括权力和薪酬不平等,以及缺乏工人补偿和福利被确定为参与者日常经历中持续存在的关键因素。
持续暴露于污名、工作场所歧视和/或权力失衡,再加上高风险工作(如处理药物过量死亡)的影响,可能会给从事减少伤害工作的有吸毒经历者带来重大后果,包括职业倦怠。政策建议包括大规模的结构性变革,以解决有吸毒经历者在层级化“同伴”就业中的不平等问题,包括增加不同有吸毒经历者的领导角色、薪酬公平和福利、工会化,以及营造更具支持性的工作环境,关注影响从事减少伤害工作的有吸毒经历者日常生活的交叉社会结构因素(贫困、刑事定罪、种族主义、性别暴力)。