Bub D N, Lewine J
Montreal Neurological Institute, Québec, Canada.
Brain Lang. 1988 Jan;33(1):161-88. doi: 10.1016/0093-934x(88)90060-0.
We confirm previous evidence indicating that word length has a substantial effect on word recognition in the LVF but a much weaker effect in both the RVF and fovea. The nature of encoding in the LVF is not altered when the words are vertically displayed (Experiment 2), and the effect cannot therefore be entirely due to scanning artefact or acuity gradients in peripheral vision. We provide evidence that links the asymmetrical influence of word length directly to hemispheric specialization: left-handers, who as a group are much less consistently lateralized than right-handers are also less affected by word length in the LVF on the average (Experiment 3). This occurs because the asymmetry for certain left-handers is either very weak or, in some cases, is the complete reverse of the asymmetry observed in right-handers. Finally, we demonstrate that the length x field interaction is observed in lexical decisions (Experiment 4) which do not entail pronunciation of written words. There is some indication that concrete, high-imageable words produce a smaller effect of length in the LVF than abstract, low-imageable words, and we discuss this outcome in relation to the proposal that the right hemisphere can sometimes extract a lexical code from letter information. The concept of distinct modes of word recognition in the LVF and RVF clarifies a number of issues in laterality research, and suggests a new approach to evaluating group differences in half-field performance.
我们证实了先前的证据,即单词长度对左视野中的单词识别有显著影响,但对右视野和中央凹的影响要弱得多。当单词垂直显示时,左视野中的编码性质不会改变(实验2),因此这种影响不可能完全归因于扫描伪影或周边视觉中的视力梯度。我们提供的证据将单词长度的不对称影响直接与半球特化联系起来:作为一个群体,左撇子的大脑半球定位比右撇子更不一致,平均而言,他们在左视野中也受单词长度的影响更小(实验3)。出现这种情况是因为某些左撇子的不对称性要么非常弱,要么在某些情况下与右撇子中观察到的不对称性完全相反。最后,我们证明在不需要读出书面单词的词汇判断中也观察到了长度×视野的交互作用(实验4)。有迹象表明,具体的、具有高形象性的单词在左视野中产生的长度效应比抽象的、低形象性的单词小,我们结合右半球有时可以从字母信息中提取词汇代码的提议来讨论这一结果。左视野和右视野中不同单词识别模式的概念澄清了偏侧性研究中的一些问题,并提出了一种评估半视野表现中群体差异的新方法。