Department of Psychology, Utah State University, Logan, UT, USA.
Cogn Behav Ther. 2021 Sep;50(5):395-408. doi: 10.1080/16506073.2020.1846609. Epub 2021 Jan 12.
Previous research indicates mixed results for guided support with online interventions. The current secondary analysis evaluated the effects of phone coaching from a dismantling trial of online acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) in a sample of 136 distressed college students randomized to one of three versions of an ACT website. Participants were randomized to receive email prompts alone (non-coaching condition) or email plus phone coaching (coaching condition). Results indicated no differences between the coaching and non-coaching conditions on program engagement, program satisfaction, mental health outcomes, and almost all psychological flexibility processes. However, participants in the coaching condition reported stronger pre- to posttreatment improvements in psychological inflexibility than the non-coaching condition. This effect was moderated by ACT component condition, with larger pre- to posttreatment effects from coaching on psychological inflexibility in the values/committed action condition and weaker improvements from coaching in the acceptance/defusion condition. Overall, results indicate online self-guided ACT interventions with email prompts are sufficient for addressing college student mental health and that phone coaching provided minimal additional benefit.
先前的研究表明,在线干预措施的引导支持效果不一。本研究对在线接受和承诺疗法(ACT)解体试验的电话辅导的效果进行了二次分析,该试验纳入了 136 名患有心理困扰的大学生,他们被随机分配到 ACT 网站的三个版本之一。参与者被随机分配到仅接受电子邮件提示(非辅导条件)或电子邮件加电话辅导(辅导条件)。结果表明,在项目参与度、项目满意度、心理健康结果以及几乎所有的心理灵活性过程方面,辅导条件与非辅导条件之间没有差异。然而,与非辅导条件相比,辅导条件的参与者报告称,在心理不灵活性方面,从治疗前到治疗后的改善更为明显。这种效果受到 ACT 成分条件的调节,在价值观/承诺行动条件下,从辅导中获得的心理不灵活性的治疗前到治疗后的效果更大,而在接受/融合条件下,从辅导中获得的改善效果较弱。总的来说,结果表明,带有电子邮件提示的在线自我指导 ACT 干预措施足以解决大学生的心理健康问题,而电话辅导提供的额外益处微乎其微。