Shruthi A H, Dinakara Deevish, Chandrika Y R
Department of Anaesthesiolgy, IGICH, Bangalore, Karnataka, India.
Consultant Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeon, Healios, Rajajinagar, Bangalore, Karnataka, India.
Indian J Anaesth. 2020 Oct;64(10):855-862. doi: 10.4103/ija.IJA_211_20. Epub 2020 Oct 1.
A number of videolaryngoscopes (VLs) have flooded the Indian market. As per All India Difficult Airway Association 2016 guidelines, all anaesthesiologists should have access to a VL and must be trained to use it. We conducted an electronic survey to know the perception of Indian anaesthesiologists, who are members of the Indian Society of Anaesthesiologists (Karnataka State Chapter) towards the role of VL in the management of difficult airway (DA) and factors governing their use.
An electronic survey was sent to 2580 ISA members to know the availability, use and attitude towards VLs in the management of DA in adults. The survey was open for a period of 2 months and responses analysed.
The response rate was 25.8% (666 out of 2580). A total of 280 (42%) respondents had access to VL. The respondents rated VL as 4 preference for anticipated DA and 1 for unanticipated DA (if available). The most widely used VLs were C-MAC, Airtraq, and Kingvision. As per 133 respondents (20%), access to VL in institutes was restricted only to consultants and the main reason being cost. The clarity of the image was the most important factor the respondents expected in a VL.
Less than half of respondents had access to VLs. Most of them having access to it worked in corporate hospitals. The high cost of the device and steep learning curve are still barriers against its widespread use. We conclude that low-cost devices, with increased clarity may make usage of VLs frequent and available to residents.
众多视频喉镜已涌入印度市场。根据全印度困难气道协会2016年指南,所有麻醉医生都应能使用视频喉镜,且必须接受使用培训。我们开展了一项电子调查,以了解印度麻醉医生(印度麻醉医师协会卡纳塔克邦分会成员)对视频喉镜在困难气道管理中的作用以及影响其使用因素的看法。
向2580名印度麻醉医师协会成员发送电子调查问卷,了解他们在成人困难气道管理中对视频喉镜的可及性、使用情况及态度。该调查为期2个月,对回复进行分析。
回复率为25.8%(2580人中666人回复)。共有280名(42%)受访者能够使用视频喉镜。受访者对视频喉镜在预期困难气道管理中的偏好评分为4分,对非预期困难气道(如有)的评分为1分。使用最广泛的视频喉镜是C-MAC、Airtraq和可视喉镜。根据133名受访者(20%)的反馈,机构中视频喉镜的使用仅限于顾问医生,主要原因是成本。图像清晰度是受访者对视频喉镜期望最高的因素。
不到一半的受访者能够使用视频喉镜。大多数能使用视频喉镜的受访者就职于私立医院。设备成本高和学习曲线陡峭仍是其广泛应用的障碍。我们得出结论,低成本且图像清晰度更高的设备可能会使视频喉镜的使用更加频繁,住院医生也能更方便地使用。