Maury A, Lyoubi A, Peiffer-Smadja N, de Broucker T, Meppiel E
Department of Neurology, centre hospitalier de Saint-Denis, hôpital Delafontaine, 93200 Saint-Denis, France.
National Institute for Health Research Health Protection Research Unit in Healthcare Associated Infections and Antimicrobial Resistance, Imperial College London, London, UK; Inserm, IAME, Université de Paris, 75018 Paris, France; Infectious and Tropical Diseases Department, Bichat-Claude-Bernard Hospital, AP-HP, 75018 Paris, France.
Rev Neurol (Paris). 2021 Jan-Feb;177(1-2):51-64. doi: 10.1016/j.neurol.2020.10.001. Epub 2020 Dec 16.
The past two decades have been marked by three epidemics linked to emerging coronaviruses. The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the existence of neurological manifestations associated with SARS-CoV-2 infection and raised the question of the neuropathogenicity of coronaviruses. The aim of this review was to summarize the current data about neurological manifestations and diseases linked to human coronaviruses.
Articles have been identified by searches of PubMed and Google scholar up to September 25, 2020, using a combination of coronavirus and neurology search terms and adding relevant references in the articles.
We found five cohorts providing prevalence data of neurological symptoms among a total of 2533 hospitalized COVID-19 patients, and articles focusing on COVID-19 patients with neurological manifestations including a total of 580 patients. Neurological symptoms involved up to 73% of COVID-19 hospitalized patients, and were mostly headache, myalgias and impaired consciousness. Central nervous system (CNS) manifestations reported in COVID-19 were mostly non-specific encephalopathies that represented between 13% and 40% of all neurological manifestations; post-infectious syndromes including acute demyelinating encephalomyelitis (ADEM, n=13), acute necrotizing encephalopathy (ANE, n=4), Bickerstaff's encephalitis (n=5), generalized myoclonus (n=3) and acute transverse myelitis (n=7); other encephalitis including limbic encephalitis (n=9) and miscellaneous encephalitis with variable radiologic findings (n=26); acute cerebrovascular diseases including ischemic strokes (between 1.3% and 4.7% of COVID-19 patients), hemorrhagic strokes (n=17), cerebral venous thrombosis (n=8) and posterior reversible encephalopathy (n=5). Peripheral nervous system (PNS) manifestations reported in COVID-19 were the following: Guillain-Barré syndrome (n=31) and variants including Miller Fisher syndrome (n=3), polyneuritis cranialis (n=2) and facial diplegia (n=2); isolated oculomotor neuropathy (n=6); critical illness myopathy (n=6). Neuropathological studies in COVID-19 patients demonstrated different patterns of CNS damage, mostly ischemic and hemorrhagic changes with few cases of inflammatory injuries. Only one case suggested SARS-CoV-2 infiltration in endothelial and neural cells. We found 10 case reports or case series describing 22 patients with neurological manifestations associated with other human coronaviruses. Among them we found four MERS patients with ADEM or Bickerstaff's encephalitis, two SARS patients with encephalitis who had a positive SARS-CoV PCR in cerebrospinal fluid, five patients with ischemic strokes associated with SARS, eight MERS patients with critical illness neuromyopathy and one MERS patient with Guillain-Barré Syndrome. An autopsy study on SARS-CoV patients demonstrated the presence of the virus in the brain of eight patients.
The wide range of neurological manifestations and diseases associated with SARS-CoV-2 is consistent with multiple pathogenic pathways including post-infectious mechanisms, septic-associated encephalopathies, coagulopathy or endothelitis. There was no definite evidence to support direct neuropathogenicity of SARS-CoV-2.
过去二十年里出现了三次与新型冠状病毒相关的疫情。新冠疫情凸显了与严重急性呼吸综合征冠状病毒2(SARS-CoV-2)感染相关的神经学表现的存在,并引发了冠状病毒神经致病性的问题。本综述的目的是总结当前关于与人类冠状病毒相关的神经学表现和疾病的数据。
通过检索PubMed和谷歌学术数据库,使用冠状病毒和神经病学搜索词的组合,并在文章中添加相关参考文献,确定截至2020年9月25日的文章。
我们发现了五个队列,提供了总共2533名住院新冠患者的神经症状患病率数据,以及专注于有神经学表现的新冠患者的文章,其中共有580名患者。神经症状在高达73%的住院新冠患者中出现,主要是头痛、肌痛和意识障碍。新冠患者中报告的中枢神经系统(CNS)表现大多是非特异性脑病,占所有神经学表现的13%至40%;感染后综合征包括急性脱髓鞘性脑脊髓炎(ADEM,n = 13)、急性坏死性脑病(ANE,n = 4)、比克斯特法夫脑炎(n = 5)、全身性肌阵挛(n = 3)和急性横贯性脊髓炎(n = 7);其他脑炎包括边缘叶脑炎(n = 9)和具有不同影像学表现的其他杂类脑炎(n = 26);急性脑血管疾病包括缺血性中风(占新冠患者的1.3%至4.7%)、出血性中风(n = 17)、脑静脉血栓形成(n = 8)和后部可逆性脑病(n = 5)。新冠患者中报告的周围神经系统(PNS)表现如下:吉兰-巴雷综合征(n = 31)及其变体,包括米勒-费希尔综合征(n = 3)、颅神经炎(n = 2)和双侧面瘫(n = 2);孤立性动眼神经病变(n = 6);危重病性肌病(n = 6)。对新冠患者的神经病理学研究显示了中枢神经系统损伤的不同模式,主要是缺血性和出血性改变,少数为炎症性损伤病例。只有一例提示SARS-CoV-2在内皮细胞和神经细胞中的浸润。我们发现10例病例报告或病例系列描述了22名与其他人类冠状病毒相关的神经学表现患者。其中我们发现4例中东呼吸综合征(MERS)患者患有ADEM或比克斯特法夫脑炎,2例严重急性呼吸综合征(SARS)患者患有脑炎,其脑脊液中SARS-CoV PCR呈阳性,5例与SARS相关的缺血性中风患者,8例MERS患者患有危重病性神经肌病,1例MERS患者患有吉兰-巴雷综合征。一项对SARS-CoV患者的尸检研究表明,8名患者的大脑中存在该病毒。
与SARS-CoV-2相关的广泛神经学表现和疾病与多种致病途径一致,包括感染后机制、脓毒症相关脑病、凝血病或内皮炎症。没有确凿证据支持SARS-CoV-2的直接神经致病性。