Department of Animal Sciences, Animal Breeding and Genetics Group, University of Goettingen, Goettingen, Germany.
Center for Integrated Breeding Research, University of Goettingen, Goettingen, Germany.
J Anim Breed Genet. 2021 Mar;138(2):137-150. doi: 10.1111/jbg.12534. Epub 2021 Jan 24.
Modern animal breeding programmes are constantly evolving with advances in breeding theory, biotechnology and genetics. Surprisingly, there seems to be no generally accepted succinct definition of what exactly a breeding programme is, neither is there a unified language to describe breeding programmes in a comprehensive, unambiguous and reproducible way. In this work, we try to fill this gap by suggesting a general definition of breeding programmes that also pertains to cases where genetic progress is not achieved through selection, but, for example, through transgenic technologies, or the aim is not to generate genetic progress, but, for example, to maintain genetic diversity. The key idea of the underlying concept is to represent a breeding programme in modular form as a directed graph that is composed of nodes and edges, where nodes represent cohorts of breeding units, usually individuals, and edges represent breeding activities, like "selection" or "reproduction." We claim, that by defining a comprehensive set of nodes and edges, it is possible to represent any breeding programme of arbitrary complexity by such a graph, which thus comprises a full description of the breeding programme. This concept is implemented in a web-based tool (MoBPSweb, available at www.mobps.de) and has a link to the R-package MoBPS (Modular Breeding Program Simulator) to simulate the described breeding programmes. The approach is illustrated by showcasing three different breeding programmes of increasing complexity. The concept allows a formal description of breeding programmes, which is requested, for example, in legal regulations of the European Union, but so far cannot be provided in a standardized format. In the discussion, we point out potential limitations of the concept and argue that the general approach can be easily extended to account for novel breeding technologies, to breeding of crops or experimental species, but also to modelling diversity dynamics in natural populations.
现代动物育种计划随着育种理论、生物技术和遗传学的进步而不断发展。令人惊讶的是,似乎没有一个普遍接受的简洁定义来准确描述什么是育种计划,也没有一个统一的语言来全面、明确和可重复地描述育种计划。在这项工作中,我们试图通过提出一个普遍的育种计划定义来填补这一空白,该定义也适用于遗传进展不是通过选择而是通过转基因技术实现的情况,或者目标不是产生遗传进展,而是例如保持遗传多样性的情况。基本概念的关键思想是以模块化形式表示育种计划,作为由节点和边组成的有向图,其中节点表示育种单位的群体,通常是个体,边表示育种活动,如“选择”或“繁殖”。我们声称,通过定义一组全面的节点和边,就有可能通过这样的图来表示任何具有任意复杂性的育种计划,从而包含对该育种计划的全面描述。该概念在基于网络的工具(MoBPSweb,可在 www.mobps.de 上获得)中实现,并与 R 包 MoBPS(模块化育种计划模拟器)有链接,以模拟所描述的育种计划。该方法通过展示三个不同的、复杂度递增的育种计划来加以说明。该概念允许对育种计划进行正式描述,这在欧盟的法规中有所要求,但目前无法以标准化的格式提供。在讨论中,我们指出了该概念的潜在局限性,并认为该通用方法可以很容易地扩展到考虑新的育种技术、作物或实验物种的育种,以及模拟自然种群中的多样性动态。