Department of Animal Science, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park 16802.
Proteomics and Mass Spectrometry Core Facility, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park 16802.
J Dairy Sci. 2021 Apr;104(4):4157-4173. doi: 10.3168/jds.2020-19686. Epub 2021 Jan 28.
Asparagopsis taxiformis (AT) is a source of multiple halogenated compounds and, in a limited number of studies, has been shown to decrease enteric CH emission in vitro and in vivo. Similarly, oregano has been suggested as a potential CH mitigating agent. This study consisted of 2 in vitro and 2 in vivo experiments. Experiment (Exp.) 1 was aimed at establishing the effect of AT on CH emission in vitro. Two experiments (Exp. 2 and 3) with lactating dairy cows were conducted to determine the antimethanogenic effect of AT and oregano (Exp. 3) in vivo. Another experiment (Exp. 4) was designed to investigate stability of bromoform (CHBr) in AT over time. In Exp. 3, 20 Holstein cows were used in a replicated 4 × 4 Latin square design with four 28-d periods. Treatments were basal diet (control) or basal diet supplemented with (dry matter basis) 0.25% AT (LowAT), 0.50% AT (HighAT), or 1.77% oregano (Origanum vulgare L.) leaves. Enteric gas emissions were measured using the GreenFeed system (C-Lock Inc., Rapid City, SD), and rumen samples were collected for fermentation analysis using the ororuminal technique. In Exp.1 (in vitro), relative to the control, AT (at 1% dry matter basis, inclusion rate) decreased CH yield by 98%. In Exp. 3, HighAT decreased average daily CH emission and CH yield by 65% and 55%, respectively, in experimental periods 1 and 2, but had no effect in periods 3 and 4. The differential response to AT among experimental periods was likely a result of a decrease in CHBr concentration in AT over time, as observed in Exp. 4 (up to 84% decrease in 4 mo of storage). In Exp. 3, H emission was increased by AT and, as expected, the proportion of acetate in the total volatile fatty acids in the rumen was decreased and those of propionate and butyrate were increased by HighAT compared with the control. Compared with the control, HighAT decreased dry matter intake, milk yield, and energy-corrected milk yield in Exp. 3. Milk composition was not affected by treatment, except lactose percentage and yield were decreased by HighAT. Concentrations of iodine and bromide in milk were increased by HighAT compared with the control. Milk CHBr concentration and its organoleptic characteristics were not different between control and HighAT. Oregano had no effect on CH emission or lactational performance of the cows in Exp. 3. Overall, AT included at 0.50% in the ration of dairy cows can have a large mitigation effect on enteric CH emission, but dry matter intake and milk production may also decrease. There was a marked decrease in the CH mitigation potential of AT in the second half of Exp. 3, likely resulting from CHBr decay over time.
泡叶藻(AT)是多种含卤素化合物的来源,在为数不多的研究中,已被证明可在体外和体内降低肠道 CH 排放。同样,牛至也被认为是一种有潜力的 CH 缓解剂。本研究包括 2 项体外和 2 项体内实验。实验 1 的目的是确定 AT 对体外 CH 排放的影响。进行了两项泌乳奶牛的实验(实验 2 和 3),以确定 AT 和牛至(实验 3)在体内的抗甲烷生成作用。另一项实验(实验 4)旨在研究 CHBr 在 AT 中的稳定性随时间的变化。在实验 3 中,使用 20 头荷斯坦奶牛,采用重复 4×4 拉丁方设计,共 4 个 28 天周期。处理为基础日粮(对照)或基础日粮添加(干物质基础)0.25%泡叶藻(低 AT)、0.50%泡叶藻(高 AT)或 1.77%牛至(牛至 vulgare L.)叶。使用 GreenFeed 系统(C-Lock Inc.,Rapid City,SD)测量肠道气体排放,使用瘤胃技术收集瘤胃液样品进行发酵分析。在实验 1(体外)中,与对照相比,AT(在 1%干物质基础,添加率)降低了 98%的 CH 产量。在实验 3 中,高 AT 在实验期 1 和 2 中分别降低了平均每日 CH 排放和 CH 产量 65%和 55%,但在实验期 3 和 4 中没有影响。实验期之间对 AT 的不同反应可能是由于 CHBr 浓度随时间的推移而降低所致,正如实验 4 中观察到的(在 4 个月的储存中最多降低 84%)。在实验 3 中,AT 增加了 H 的排放,并且如预期的那样,高 AT 降低了瘤胃中总挥发性脂肪酸中乙酸的比例,增加了丙酸和丁酸的比例。与对照相比,高 AT 降低了干物质采食量、产奶量和能量校正奶产量。处理对牛奶成分没有影响,但高 AT 降低了乳糖百分比和产量。与对照相比,高 AT 增加了牛奶中的碘和溴的浓度。高 AT 对控制和高 AT 之间的牛奶 CHBr 浓度及其感官特性没有影响。牛至对奶牛的 CH 排放或泌乳性能在实验 3 中没有影响。总体而言,奶牛日粮中添加 0.50%的泡叶藻可以对肠道 CH 排放产生很大的缓解作用,但干物质采食量和产奶量也可能下降。在实验 3 的后半段,泡叶藻的 CH 缓解潜力明显下降,可能是由于 CHBr 随时间的推移而衰减。