Traga Philippakos Zoi A, Voggt Ashley
University of Tennessee, Knoxville, USA.
Texas A&M University, Corpus Christi, USA.
Read Writ. 2021;34(7):1791-1822. doi: 10.1007/s11145-021-10120-1. Epub 2021 Jan 25.
The purpose of the study was to examine the feasibility and effectiveness of a distant-professional development model that supported the implementation of genre-based strategy instruction for procedural writing on second grade teachers' fidelity of implementation and students' writing quality. Participants were 84 s graders and four teachers who were randomly assigned to condition. Teachers completed an online workshop module prior to instruction, a survey on their instruction and confidence to teach writing, received coaching feedback during implementation, and were interviewed at pretest and posttest. Students wrote in response to two procedural topics at pretest and posttest, at maintenance, completed transfer tasks in science and in persuasion, were interviewed at posttest, completed a confidence scale, and standardized measures. Results showed that treatment teachers positively evaluated the PD and its components, taught with high fidelity, and positively commented on the instructional approach. Treatment students wrote papers of better quality at posttest and maintenance tasks, while there were no statistically significant differences at the transfer tasks, on students' confidence, and on standardized measures. Implications for professional development, practice, and research are further discussed.
本研究的目的是检验一种远程专业发展模式的可行性和有效性,该模式支持为二年级教师实施基于体裁的策略教学,以教授程序性写作,并考察其对实施保真度和学生写作质量的影响。研究参与者为84名二年级学生和4名教师,他们被随机分配到不同条件组。教师在教学前完成一个在线工作坊模块,填写一份关于其教学及写作教学信心的调查问卷,在实施过程中接受指导反馈,并在预测试和后测试时接受访谈。学生在预测试和后测试时针对两个程序性主题进行写作,在维持阶段,完成科学和说服性写作的迁移任务,在测试后接受访谈,完成一份信心量表以及标准化测试。结果表明,接受培训的教师对专业发展及其组成部分给予了积极评价,教学保真度高,并对教学方法给予了积极评价。接受培训的学生在测试后和维持任务中的写作质量更高,而在迁移任务、学生信心和标准化测试方面没有统计学上的显著差异。文中进一步讨论了该研究对专业发展、实践和研究的启示。