Cuadros Olga, Leal-Soto Francisco, Rubio Andrés, Sánchez Benjamín
Centro de Investigación para la Educación Inclusiva, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso, Viña del Mar, Chile.
Departamento de Ciencias Sociales, Universidad de Tarapacá, Iquique, Chile.
Front Psychol. 2021 Jan 15;11:620011. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.620011. eCollection 2020.
Chile has established hybrid policies for the administrative distribution of its educational establishments, leading to significant gaps in educational results and school conditions between public, mixed, and private schools. As a result, there are high levels of segregation, and social and economic vulnerability that put public schools at a disadvantage, affecting their image and causing a constant decrease in enrollment. An abbreviated version of Luhtanen and Crocker's (1992) collective self-esteem scale was adapted and validated for the Chilean educational context because of its usefulness in studying processes of social segregation and cultural coherence, seeking to identify student perception about the appreciation of school actions in the context of belonging and identification with schools, in order to compare between groups according to types of establishment and assess the effects of school conditions on the perception of students. A representative sample of Chilean secondary students between 9th and 12th grades participated ( = 3635, 52.8% women, average age 15.9 years, = 1.1). Descriptive analyses, comparison of means between groups, confirmatory factorial analyses, and multi-group analyses were conducted to test the adjustment and invariance of the unifactorial structure of a reduced version of four items. The results indicated that the scale satisfactorily complies with the proposed adjustment indexes, presents total invariance by gender and partial invariance by administrative dependence, and allows establishing statistically significant differences in the collective self-esteem, indicating a higher score for students in the private system, and a lower score for those in the public system. These results show the negative effects of high school segregation on students' collective self-esteem, affecting the appreciation of personal, collective, and institutional activities and the sense of belonging. Although previous research has explored some of the effects of school segregation, the present study focuses on collective self-esteem, which is closely related to identity and belonging, and allows for further innovative research on school segregation. The scale is useful as an instrument for researching social conditions of student well-being, in regards to educational management.
智利为其教育机构的行政分配制定了混合政策,导致公立、混合和私立学校在教育成果和学校条件方面存在显著差距。结果,出现了高度的隔离以及社会和经济脆弱性,使公立学校处于不利地位,影响了它们的形象,并导致入学率持续下降。由于Luhtanen和Crocker(1992)的集体自尊量表在研究社会隔离和文化一致性过程中很有用,因此对其进行了简化版本的改编并在智利教育背景下进行了验证,旨在确定学生在归属和认同学校的背景下对学校行为认可度的看法,以便根据学校类型在不同群体之间进行比较,并评估学校条件对学生认知的影响。智利9至12年级的中学生代表样本参与了研究(n = 3635,52.8%为女性,平均年龄15.9岁,SD = 1.1)。进行了描述性分析