Shi G, Subramanian S, Cao Q, Demehri S, Siewerdsen J H, Zbijewski W
Department of Biomedical Engineering, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD USA 21205.
Russell H. Morgan Department of Radiology, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD USA 21287.
Proc SPIE Int Soc Opt Eng. 2020 Feb;11317. doi: 10.1117/12.2552385. Epub 2020 Mar 5.
To evaluate the performance of a novel ultra-high resolution multi-detector CT scanner (Canon Aquilion Precision UHR CT), capable of visualizing ~150 μm details, in quantitative assessment of bone microarchitecture. Compared to conventional CT, the spatial resolution of UHR CT begins to approach the size of the trabeculae. This might enable measurements of microstructural correlates of osteoporosis, osteoarthritis, and other bone disease.
The UHR CT system features a 160-row x-ray detector with 250×250 μm pixels (measured at isocenter) and a custom-designed x-ray source with a 0.4×0.5 mm focal spot. Visualization of high contrast details down to ~150 μm has been achieved on this device, which is now commercially available for clinical use. To evaluate the performance of UHR CT in quantification of bone microstructure, we imaged a variety of human bone samples (including ulna, radius, and vertebrae) embedded in a ~16 cm diameter plastic cylinder and in an anthropomorphic thorax phantom (QRM-Thorax, QRM Gmbh). Helical UHR CT acquisitions (120 kVp tube voltage) were acquired at scan exposures of 375 mAs - 5 mAs. For comparison, the samples were also imaged using a Normal Resolution (NR) mode available on the scanner, involving 500 μm slice thickness, exposure of 50 mAs, and a focal spot of 0.6×1.3 mm. We obtained micro-CT (μCT) of the bone samples at ~28 μm voxel size as a gold-standard reference. Geometric measurements of bone microstructure were performed in 17 regions-of-interests (ROIs) distributed throughout the bones of the phantoms; image registration was used to place the ROIs at corresponding locations in the UHR CT and NR CT. Trabecular thickness Tb.Th, spacing Tb.Sp, and Bone Volume fraction BvTv were obtained. The UHR and NR imaging protocols were compared terms of correlations to μCT and error of trabecular measurements. The effect of dose on trabecular morphometry was also studied for the UHR CT. Furthermore, we evaluated the sensitivity of texture features of trabecular bone (recently proposed as an alternative to geometric indices of microstructure) to imaging protocol. Image texture evaluation was performed using ~150 regions of interest (ROIs) across all bone samples. Three-dimensional Gray Level Co-occurrence Matrix (GLCM) and Gray Level Run Length Matrix (GLRM) features were extracted for each ROI. We analyzed correlation and concordance correlation coefficient (CCC) of the mean ROI values of texture features obtained using the UHR and NR modes.
UHR CT reconstructions of bone samples clearly demonstrated improved visualization of the trabeculae compared to NR CT. UHR CT achieved substantially better correlations for all three metrics of bone microstructure, in particular for BvTv (correlation coefficient of 0.91 for UHR CT compared to 0.84 for NR CT) and TbSp (correlation of 0.74 for UHR CT and 0.047 for NR CT). The error obtained with UHR CT was generally smaller than that of NR CT. For TbSp, the mean deviation from μCT (averaged across all bone samples) was only ~0.07 for UHR CT, compared to 0.25 for NR CT. Analysis of reproducibility of texture features of trabecular bone between UHR CT and NR CT revealed fair correlations (>0.7) for the majority of GLCM features, but relatively poor CCC (e.g. 0.02 for Energy and 0.04 for Entropy). The magnitude of texture metrics is particularly affected by the enhanced spatial resolution of UHR CT.
The recently introduced UHR CT achieves improved correlation and reduced error in measurements of trabecular bone microstructure compared to conventional resolution CT. Future development of diagnostic strategies based on textural biomarkers derived from UHR CT will need to account for potential sensitivity of texture features to image resolution.
评估一款新型超高分辨率多探测器CT扫描仪(佳能Aquilion Precision UHR CT)在骨微结构定量评估中的性能,该扫描仪能够可视化约150μm的细节。与传统CT相比,UHR CT的空间分辨率开始接近小梁的尺寸。这可能使我们能够测量骨质疏松症、骨关节炎和其他骨疾病的微观结构相关性。
UHR CT系统具有一个160排X射线探测器,像素为250×250μm(在等中心测量),以及一个定制设计的X射线源,焦点为0.4×0.5mm。在该设备上已实现对低至约150μm的高对比度细节的可视化,该设备现已商业化用于临床。为了评估UHR CT在骨微结构定量方面的性能,我们对嵌入直径约16cm塑料圆柱体和拟人化胸部模型(QRM-Thorax,QRM有限公司)中的各种人体骨样本(包括尺骨、桡骨和椎骨)进行了成像。在375mAs - 5mAs的扫描曝光下进行螺旋UHR CT采集(管电压120kVp)。作为对比,还使用该扫描仪上的常规分辨率(NR)模式对样本进行成像,包括500μm的层厚、50mAs的曝光和0.6×1.3mm的焦点。我们以约28μm的体素大小获得骨样本的微CT(μCT)作为金标准参考。在分布于模型骨骼各处的17个感兴趣区域(ROI)中进行骨微结构的几何测量;使用图像配准将ROI放置在UHR CT和NR CT的相应位置。获得小梁厚度Tb.Th、间距Tb.Sp和骨体积分数BvTv。比较了UHR和NR成像协议与μCT的相关性以及小梁测量的误差。还研究了剂量对UHR CT小梁形态计量学的影响。此外,我们评估了小梁骨纹理特征(最近被提议作为微观结构几何指标的替代方法)对成像协议的敏感性。使用所有骨样本上的约150个感兴趣区域(ROI)进行图像纹理评估。为每个ROI提取三维灰度共生矩阵(GLCM)和灰度游程长度矩阵(GLRM)特征。我们分析了使用UHR和NR模式获得的纹理特征的平均ROI值的相关性和一致性相关系数(CCC)。
与NR CT相比,骨样本的UHR CT重建清楚地显示出小梁的可视化得到改善。UHR CT在骨微结构的所有三个指标上都实现了显著更好的相关性,特别是对于BvTv(UHR CT的相关系数为0.91,而NR CT为0.84)和TbSp(UHR CT的相关性为0.74,NR CT为0.047)。UHR CT获得的误差通常小于NR CT。对于TbSp,与μCT的平均偏差(在所有骨样本上平均)对于UHR CT仅约为0.07,而NR CT为0.25。UHR CT和NR CT之间小梁骨纹理特征再现性的分析表明,大多数GLCM特征具有中等相关性(>0.7),但CCC相对较差(例如能量为0.02,熵为0.04)。纹理指标的大小特别受UHR CT增强的空间分辨率的影响。
与传统分辨率CT相比,最近推出的UHR CT在小梁骨微结构测量中实现了更好的相关性和更低的误差。基于UHR CT衍生的纹理生物标志物的诊断策略的未来发展将需要考虑纹理特征对图像分辨率的潜在敏感性。