Department of Sociology, University of Calgary and Fellow, Centre for Criminology, University of Hong Kong.
Department of Sociology, Memorial University of Newfoundland.
Can Rev Sociol. 2021 Feb;58(1):45-64. doi: 10.1111/cars.12319. Epub 2021 Feb 18.
"Addiction" to internet-connected technology continues to dominate media discourses of young people. Researchers have identified negative outcomes, including decreased mental health, resulting from anxieties related to technology, e.g., a fear of missing out and social connectivity related to online technologies. Not enough is known, however, regarding young people's own responses to these ideas. This paper highlights discussions with teenagers around the idea of internet addiction, exploring their experiences and perceptions regarding the idea that "kids today" are addicted to their devices, especially smartphones and the social network sites they often access from them. Thirty-five focus group discussions with 115 Canadian teenagers (aged 13-19 years old) center on their use of information communication technologies, especially contemporary social network sites such as Snapchat, Instagram and Facebook. Our discussions reveal (1) that teens are actively embracing the label of addiction; (2) their ironic positioning occurs despite a felt sense of debased agency in relation to the power of the algorithms and affordances of the technologies mediating their use; and (3) rather than a stark divide between adults as "digital immigrants" versus young people as "digital natives," our teens positioned themselves in contrast to both their parents and younger siblings, both of whom are criticized as addicted themselves. A consistent theme is the influence of peer groups who socially compel addictive behaviours, including the fear of missing out, rather than the technologies per se. Wider implications for thinking beyond solely young people as suffering from online addiction are considered.
“对互联网连接技术的沉迷”继续主导着关于年轻人的媒体话语。研究人员已经确定了一些负面结果,包括由于与技术相关的焦虑而导致的心理健康下降,例如错过和与在线技术相关的社交联系的恐惧。然而,关于年轻人对这些想法的反应,人们知之甚少。本文重点讨论了青少年对网络成瘾的看法,探讨了他们对“现在的孩子”沉迷于自己的设备(尤其是智能手机以及他们经常从中访问的社交网络)的看法和感受。对 35 个焦点小组讨论的分析,共涉及 115 名加拿大青少年(年龄在 13 到 19 岁之间),重点关注他们对信息通信技术的使用,特别是当代社交网络,如 Snapchat、Instagram 和 Facebook。我们的讨论揭示了以下几点:(1)青少年积极接受沉迷标签;(2)尽管他们感到自己的代理能力下降,与算法的力量和技术的使用功能相比,他们的讽刺立场仍然存在;(3)与成年人是“数字移民”而年轻人是“数字原住民”之间的明显分歧不同,我们的青少年将自己定位为与父母和年幼的兄弟姐妹相对立,他们都被批评为自己沉迷于此。一个一致的主题是同龄人社交上迫使他们沉迷的行为,包括错过恐惧,而不是技术本身。还考虑了超越单纯认为年轻人受到网络成瘾影响的更广泛的影响。