Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, University Hospitals Coventry and Warwickshire, Clifford Bridge Rd, Coventry, CV2 2DX, UK.
Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2021 Dec;25(4):519-524. doi: 10.1007/s10006-021-00941-3. Epub 2021 Feb 20.
Healthcare information is becoming more readily available and searched for online, particularly on websites such as YouTube™. The accuracy and content of these websites is often questionable. We aimed to evaluate the quality of information available on surgical extraction of wisdom teeth on YouTube™.
We searched for the terms 'wisdom teeth', 'third molar', and 'wisdom tooth extraction' on YouTube™. The first 3 pages of results for each search term were assessed for inclusion and were independently rated by two assessors. Three separate scales to rate the quality of online information were used-DICSERN (range 0-5), HONcode (range 0-8) and the Global Quality Scale (GQS)(range 1-5). Cohen's kappa test was used to assess inter-rater reliability.
The searches returned 179 videos, but 114 were excluded (37 duplicates, 3 unrelated, 57 non-surgical, 13 <10k views, 4 non-English). Of the 65 videos included, the average length was 6 minutes and 34 seconds, and the average percentage positivity was 89%. The mean DISCERN score was 1.47 (SD 1.13), and the mean score for GQS was 2.15 (SD 0.6). No video met all HONcode criteria with the mean score being 2.96 (SD 0.9). There was good inter-rater reliability for the DISCERN score (kappa= 0.744) and HONcode score (kappa =0.866) but less reliability for GQS (kappa = 0.204).
The standard of information on YouTube™ on surgical extraction of wisdom teeth varies, but is of poor quality overall. Patients should be advised to be cautious of such sources for information on this topic.
医疗保健信息在网上变得越来越容易获取和搜索,特别是在 YouTube™ 等网站上。这些网站的准确性和内容往往值得怀疑。我们旨在评估 YouTube™ 上关于外科拔除智齿的可用信息的质量。
我们在 YouTube™ 上搜索了“智齿”、“第三磨牙”和“智齿拔除”等术语。每个搜索词的前 3 页结果都被评估是否包含在内,并由两名评估员进行独立评估。使用三个独立的评分标准来评估在线信息的质量-DICSERN(范围 0-5)、HONcode(范围 0-8)和全球质量评分(GQS)(范围 1-5)。使用 Cohen's kappa 检验评估组内一致性。
搜索结果返回了 179 个视频,但有 114 个被排除在外(37 个重复,3 个不相关,57 个非手术,13 个观看量<10k,4 个非英语)。在纳入的 65 个视频中,平均长度为 6 分 34 秒,平均阳性率为 89%。平均 DISCERN 得分为 1.47(SD 1.13),平均 GQS 得分为 2.15(SD 0.6)。没有一个视频符合所有 HONcode 标准,平均得分为 2.96(SD 0.9)。DISCERN 评分(kappa=0.744)和 HONcode 评分(kappa=0.866)的组内一致性良好,但 GQS 的一致性较差(kappa=0.204)。
YouTube™ 上关于外科拔除智齿的信息标准各不相同,但总体质量较差。应该建议患者在获取关于这个主题的信息时要谨慎使用此类来源。