Shao Shih-Chieh, Lai Edward Chia-Cheng, Huang Tse-Hung, Hung Ming-Jui, Tsai Ming-Shao, Yang Yao-Hsu, Chan Yuk-Ying
Department of Pharmacy, Keelung Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Keelung, Taiwan.
School of Pharmacy, Institute of Clinical Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences, College of Medicine, National Cheng Kung University, Tainan, Taiwan.
Pharmacoepidemiol Drug Saf. 2021 May;30(5):652-660. doi: 10.1002/pds.5208. Epub 2021 Mar 5.
The Chang Gung Research Database (CGRD), the largest multi-institutional electronic medical records collection in Taiwan, has been used to establish real-world evidence related to traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). We aimed to evaluate patient characteristics and representativeness of TCM patients in CGRD.
We identified a cohort of patients who had TCM records both from CGRD and from Taiwan's National Health Insurance Database (NHIRD) during 2010-2015 to investigate the representativeness of CGRD for TCM uses. The NHIRD was considered as reference because it covers all medical claims from 99.9% of the entire Taiwanese population. We investigated the coverage rates of TCM patients within CGRD compared to NHIRD, and compared the characteristics of patients between CGRD and NHIRD including age, sex, and 15 health conditions.
We identified 71 002 average annual patients within the CGRD, which accounted for 1.1% of the patients from the NHIRD. The patients from CGRD were older than those from NHIRD (≥65: 16.6% vs. 9.9% for CGRD vs. NHIRD). The ratios of female over male patients were 1.7 vs. 1.5 for CGRD vs. NHIRD. We found higher patient coverage rates for patients with major comorbidities in CGRD, specifically for neoplasm (9.2%) and mental disorders (6.0%). The most frequently prescribed Chinese herbal medicines in CGRD included Jia-Wei-Xiao-Yao-San, Xiang-Sha-Liu-Jun-Zi-Tang and Gui-Lu-Er-Xian-Jiao.
Higher patient coverage rates were found in CGRD for TCM patients with major comorbidities. Investigators should note possible selection bias since TCM patient disorders may be more severe in CGRD than in the NHIRD.
长庚研究数据库(CGRD)是台湾最大的多机构电子病历集合,已被用于建立与传统中医(TCM)相关的真实世界证据。我们旨在评估CGRD中中医患者的特征和代表性。
我们确定了一组在2010 - 2015年期间同时拥有CGRD和台湾国民健康保险数据库(NHIRD)中医记录的患者队列,以调查CGRD在中医使用方面的代表性。NHIRD被视为参考,因为它涵盖了全台湾99.9%人口的所有医疗索赔。我们调查了CGRD中与NHIRD相比的中医患者覆盖率,并比较了CGRD和NHIRD之间患者的特征,包括年龄、性别和15种健康状况。
我们在CGRD中确定了平均每年71002名患者,占NHIRD患者的1.1%。CGRD中的患者比NHIRD中的患者年龄更大(≥65岁:CGRD为16.6%,NHIRD为9.9%)。CGRD中女性患者与男性患者的比例为1.7,NHIRD中为1.5。我们发现CGRD中患有主要合并症的患者覆盖率更高,特别是肿瘤(9.2%)和精神障碍(6.0%)。CGRD中最常开具的中药包括加味逍遥散、香砂六君子汤和龟鹿二仙胶。
CGRD中患有主要合并症的中医患者覆盖率更高。研究人员应注意可能存在的选择偏倚,因为CGRD中的中医患者疾病可能比NHIRD中的更严重。