Pollock Nira R, Jacobs Jesica R, Tran Kristine, Cranston Amber E, Smith Sita, O'Kane Claire Y, Roady Tyler J, Moran Anne, Scarry Alison, Carroll Melissa, Volinsky Leila, Perez Gloria, Patel Pinal, Gabriel Stacey, Lennon Niall J, Madoff Lawrence C, Brown Catherine, Smole Sandra C
Department of Laboratory Medicine, Boston Children's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, USA
Massachusetts Department of Public Health, Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts, USA.
J Clin Microbiol. 2021 Apr 20;59(5). doi: 10.1128/JCM.00083-21.
Rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) for SARS-CoV-2 antigens (Ag) that can be performed at point of care (POC) can supplement molecular testing and help mitigate the COVID-19 pandemic. Deployment of an Ag RDT requires an understanding of its operational and performance characteristics under real-world conditions and in relevant subpopulations. We evaluated the Abbott BinaxNOW COVID-19 Ag card in a high-throughput, drive-through, free community testing site in Massachusetts using anterior nasal (AN) swab reverse transcriptase PCR (RT-PCR) for clinical testing. Individuals presenting for molecular testing in two of seven lanes were offered the opportunity to also receive BinaxNOW testing. Dual AN swabs were collected from symptomatic and asymptomatic children (≤18 years of age) and adults. BinaxNOW testing was performed in a testing pod with temperature/humidity monitoring. One individual performed testing and official result reporting for each test, but most tests had a second independent reading to assess interoperator agreement. Positive BinaxNOW results were scored as faint, medium, or strong. Positive BinaxNOW results were reported to patients by phone, and they were instructed to isolate pending RT-PCR results. The paired RT-PCR result was the reference for sensitivity and specificity calculations. Of 2,482 participants, 1,380 adults and 928 children had paired RT-PCR/BinaxNOW results and complete symptom data. In this study, 974/1,380 (71%) adults and 829/928 (89%) children were asymptomatic. BinaxNOW had 96.5% (95% confidence interval [CI], 90.0 to 99.3) sensitivity and 100% (95% CI, 98.6 to 100.0) specificity in adults within 7 days of symptoms and 84.6% (95% CI, 65.1 to 95.6) sensitivity and 100% (95% CI, 94.5 to 100.0) specificity in children within 7 days of symptoms. Sensitivity and specificity in asymptomatic adults were 70.2% (95% CI, 56.6 to 81.6) and 99.6% (95% CI, 98.9 to 99.9), respectively, and in asymptomatic children, they were 65.4% (95% CI, 55.6 to 74.4) and 99.0% (95% CI, 98.0 to 99.6), respectively. By cycle threshold ( ) value cutoff, sensitivity in all subgroups combined ( = 292 RT-PCR-positive individuals) was 99.3% with values of ≤25, 95.8% with values of ≤30, and 81.2% with values of ≤35. Twelve false-positive BinaxNOW results (out of 2,308 tests) were observed; in all 12, the test bands were faint but otherwise normal and were noted by both readers. One invalid BinaxNOW result was identified. Interoperator agreement (positive versus negative BinaxNOW result) was 100% ( = 2,230/2,230 double reads). Each operator was able to process 20 RDTs per hour. In a separate set of 30 specimens (from individuals with symptoms ≤7 days) run at temperatures below the manufacturer's recommended range (46 to 58.5°F), sensitivity was 66.7% and specificity 95.2%. BinaxNOW had very high specificity in both adults and children and very high sensitivity in newly symptomatic adults. Overall, 95.8% sensitivity was observed with values of ≤30. These data support public health recommendations for use of the BinaxNOW test in adults with symptoms for ≤7 days without RT-PCR confirmation. Excellent interoperator agreement indicates that an individual can perform and read the BinaxNOW test alone. A skilled laboratorian can perform and read 20 tests per hour. Careful attention to temperature is critical.
用于严重急性呼吸综合征冠状病毒2(SARS-CoV-2)抗原(Ag)的快速诊断测试(RDT)可在护理点(POC)进行,能够补充分子检测并有助于缓解2019冠状病毒病大流行。部署抗原快速诊断测试需要了解其在实际条件下和相关亚人群中的操作及性能特征。我们在马萨诸塞州一个高通量、免下车的免费社区检测点,使用前鼻(AN)拭子逆转录聚合酶链反应(RT-PCR)进行临床检测,对雅培BinaxNOW 2019冠状病毒病抗原检测卡进行了评估。在七个检测通道中的两个通道进行分子检测的个体,也有机会接受BinaxNOW检测。对有症状和无症状的儿童(≤18岁)及成人采集双份前鼻拭子。BinaxNOW检测在一个有温度/湿度监测的检测舱内进行。每次检测由一人进行检测及报告正式结果,但大多数检测有第二次独立判读以评估不同操作人员之间的一致性。BinaxNOW检测呈阳性的结果分为弱阳性、中等阳性或强阳性。BinaxNOW检测呈阳性的结果通过电话告知患者,并指示他们在等待RT-PCR结果期间进行隔离。配对的RT-PCR结果作为敏感性和特异性计算的参考。在2482名参与者中,1380名成人和928名儿童有配对的RT-PCR/BinaxNOW结果及完整的症状数据。在本研究中,974/1380(71%)的成人和829/928(89%)的儿童无症状。BinaxNOW在症状出现7天内的成人中的敏感性为96.5%(95%置信区间[CI],90.0至99.3),特异性为100%(95%CI,98.6至100.0);在症状出现7天内的儿童中的敏感性为84.6%(95%CI,65.1至95.6),特异性为100%(95%CI,94.5至100.0)。无症状成人的敏感性和特异性分别为70.2%(95%CI,56.6至81.6)和99.6%(95%CI,98.9至99.9),无症状儿童的敏感性和特异性分别为65.4%(95%CI,55.6至74.4)和99.0%(95%CI,98.0至99.6)。根据循环阈值( )值截断,所有亚组合并( = 292例RT-PCR阳性个体)时,当 值≤25时敏感性为99.3%,当 值≤30时敏感性为95.8%,当 值≤35时敏感性为81.2%。观察到12例假阳性BinaxNOW结果(在2308次检测中);在所有12例中,检测条带为弱阳性但其他方面正常,两位判读者均有记录。识别出1例无效的BinaxNOW结果。不同操作人员之间的一致性(BinaxNOW检测结果阳性与阴性)为100%( = 2230/2230次双份判读)。每个操作人员每小时能够处理20次快速诊断测试。在另一组30份标本(来自症状出现≤7天的个体)中,在低于制造商推荐范围(46至58.5°F)的温度下进行检测,敏感性为66.7%,特异性为95.2%。BinaxNOW在成人和儿童中均具有非常高的特异性,在新出现症状的成人中具有非常高的敏感性。总体而言,当 值≤30时观察到敏感性为95.8%。这些数据支持在无RT-PCR确认的情况下,对症状出现≤7天的成人使用BinaxNOW检测的公共卫生建议。出色的不同操作人员之间一致性表明一个人可以单独进行和判读BinaxNOW检测。一名熟练的检验人员每小时能够进行并判读20次检测。仔细注意温度至关重要。