McNorgan Chris
Department of Psychology, University at Buffalo, Buffalo, NY, United States.
Front Comput Neurosci. 2021 Feb 12;15:590093. doi: 10.3389/fncom.2021.590093. eCollection 2021.
The capacity to produce and understand written language is a uniquely human skill that exists on a continuum, and foundational to other facets of human cognition. Multivariate classifiers based on support vector machines (SVM) have provided much insight into the networks underlying reading skill beyond what traditional univariate methods can tell us. Shallow models like SVM require large amounts of data, and this problem is compounded when functional connections, which increase exponentially with network size, are predictors of interest. Data reduction using independent component analyses (ICA) mitigates this problem, but conventionally assumes linear relationships. Multilayer feedforward networks, in contrast, readily find optimal low-dimensional encodings of complex patterns that include complex nonlinear or conditional relationships. Samples of poor and highly-skilled young readers were selected from two open access data sets using rhyming and mental multiplication tasks, respectively. Functional connectivity was computed for the rhyming task within a functionally-defined reading network and used to train multilayer feedforward classifier models to simultaneously associate functional connectivity patterns with lexicality (word vs. pseudoword) and reading skill (poor vs. highly-skilled). Classifiers identified validation set lexicality with significantly better than chance accuracy, and reading skill with near-ceiling accuracy. Critically, a series of replications used pre-trained rhyming-task models to classify reading skill from mental multiplication task participants' connectivity with near-ceiling accuracy. The novel deep learning approach presented here provides the clearest demonstration to date that reading-skill dependent functional connectivity within the reading network influences brain processing dynamics across cognitive domains.
产生和理解书面语言的能力是一种独特的人类技能,它存在于一个连续体上,并且是人类认知其他方面的基础。基于支持向量机(SVM)的多变量分类器为我们提供了许多关于阅读技能背后网络的见解,这是传统单变量方法无法做到的。像SVM这样的浅层模型需要大量数据,而当功能连接(其随着网络大小呈指数增长)作为感兴趣的预测因子时,这个问题会更加复杂。使用独立成分分析(ICA)进行数据降维可以缓解这个问题,但传统上假设存在线性关系。相比之下,多层前馈网络能够轻松找到复杂模式的最优低维编码,这些模式包括复杂的非线性或条件关系。分别使用押韵任务和心算任务从两个开放获取的数据集中选取了阅读能力差和阅读能力强的年轻读者样本。在功能定义的阅读网络内计算押韵任务的功能连接性,并用于训练多层前馈分类器模型,以便同时将功能连接模式与词汇性(单词与假词)和阅读技能(差与强)相关联。分类器识别验证集词汇性的准确率显著高于随机水平,识别阅读技能的准确率接近上限。至关重要的是,一系列重复实验使用预训练的押韵任务模型,以接近上限的准确率从心算任务参与者的连接性中对阅读技能进行分类。这里提出的新颖深度学习方法提供了迄今为止最清晰的证明,即阅读网络内依赖于阅读技能的功能连接会影响跨认知领域的大脑处理动态。