Department of Biomedical Engineering, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL, USA.
Center for Bionic Medicine, Shirley Ryan AbilityLab, Chicago, IL, USA.
Sci Rep. 2021 Mar 4;11(1):5158. doi: 10.1038/s41598-021-84795-5.
Accurate control of human limbs involves both feedforward and feedback signals. For prosthetic arms, feedforward control is commonly accomplished by recording myoelectric signals from the residual limb to predict the user's intent, but augmented feedback signals are not explicitly provided in commercial devices. Previous studies have demonstrated inconsistent results when artificial feedback was provided in the presence of vision; some studies showed benefits, while others did not. We hypothesized that negligible benefits in past studies may have been due to artificial feedback with low precision compared to vision, which results in heavy reliance on vision during reaching tasks. Furthermore, we anticipated more reliable benefits from artificial feedback when providing information that vision estimates with high uncertainty (e.g. joint speed). In this study, we test an artificial sensory feedback system providing joint speed information and how it impacts performance and adaptation during a hybrid positional-and-myoelectric ballistic reaching task. We found that overall reaching errors were reduced after perturbed control, but did not significantly improve steady-state reaches. Furthermore, we found that feedback about the joint speed of the myoelectric prosthesis control improved the adaptation rate of biological limb movements, which may have resulted from high prosthesis control noise and strategic overreaching with the positional control and underreaching with the myoelectric control. These results provide insights into the relevant factors influencing the improvements conferred by artificial sensory feedback.
准确控制人体肢体既需要前馈信号,也需要反馈信号。对于假肢,前馈控制通常通过记录残肢的肌电信号来预测用户的意图来实现,但商业设备中并未明确提供增强的反馈信号。之前的研究表明,在存在视觉的情况下提供人工反馈时,结果并不一致;一些研究表明有益,而另一些则没有。我们假设过去研究中微不足道的益处可能是由于与视觉相比,人工反馈的精度较低,这导致在进行伸展任务时严重依赖视觉。此外,我们预计在提供视觉估计具有高不确定性的信息(例如关节速度)时,人工反馈会带来更可靠的益处。在这项研究中,我们测试了一种提供关节速度信息的人工感觉反馈系统,以及它如何影响混合位置和肌电弹道伸展任务中的性能和适应能力。我们发现,在受扰控制后,整体伸展误差有所减少,但在稳定状态伸展时并没有显著改善。此外,我们发现,关于肌电假肢控制的关节速度的反馈改善了生物肢体运动的适应速度,这可能是由于假肢控制噪声较高,以及位置控制的过度伸展和肌电控制的不足所致。这些结果为理解影响人工感觉反馈带来的改善的相关因素提供了思路。