Péloquin Sophie, Schmierer Klaus, Leist Thomas P, Oh Jiwon, Murray Suzanne, Lazure Patrice
AXDEV Group Inc., Brossard, Canada.
Queen Mary University of London, Barts and The London School of Medicine & Dentistry, The Blizard Institute (Neuroscience, Surgery and Trauma), London, United Kingdom; Barts Health NHS Trust, Clinical Board Medicine (Neuroscience), The Royal London Hospital, London, United Kingdom.
Mult Scler Relat Disord. 2021 May;50:102854. doi: 10.1016/j.msard.2021.102854. Epub 2021 Feb 23.
Disease-modifying treatment (DMT) selection for people with multiple sclerosis (MS) is challenging. Neurologists and advanced practice nurses (APNs) in MS care may be facing knowledge and confidence gaps when screening patients to initiate or switch between DMTs, assessing the safety of new DMTs and monitoring for adverse events. Healthcare providers are required to demonstrate enhanced patient communication skills, to share treatment decisions and assess treatment adherence. To better inform educational interventions, there is a need to better understand these challenges and uncover their causalities. We undertook an international study across seven countries to identify challenges for neurologists and APNs that may impact DMT choices and optimum care for people with MS (pwMS).
This mixed methods study involved two concurrent data collection phases, a qualitative phase with semi-structured interviews and a quantitative phase using an online survey. Neurologists (n=333) and APNs (n=135) were recruited from Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, United Kingdom and the United States. All participants had to have a minimum of two years' experience in the care of pwMS and be currently active in clinical practice.
A triangulated analysis of qualitative and quantitative data identified multiple challenges. For APNs, these mainly related to diagnosing MS, integrating new agents in their practice, sequential DMT selection, treatment monitoring and providing personalized care. Specifically, two-thirds of APNs reported no or basic knowledge of the 2017 McDonald criteria and over half reported a knowledge gap of new DMTs available (51%) and a skill gap when integrating them into practice (58%). APNs expressed a knowledge gap of treatment sequencing (46%) and a skill gap in making decisions about sequencing (62%). Forty-four percent of APNs reported a gap in their skills of integrating patient's goals into treatment recommendations. For neurologists, the main challenges included managing side effects, aligning care to their patient's personal goals and quality of life (QoL). Specifically, over a third of neurologists reported no or basic knowledge of the characteristics of treatment failure (35%), and 32% reported no or basic skills identifying treatment failure. Skills needed to integrate patient's individual goals into treatment recommendations were reported as none or low by 39% of neurologists. In addition, there were significant differences according to years of practice in the majority (9 out of 14) of confidence items with respect to discussing specific MS-related topics with patients. Significant differences between countries were also identified.
The complexity of diagnosing MS and the variety of available DMTs for pwMS lead to uncertainties, even among specialized healthcare professionals. These should be addressed through focused education and training to optimize care for pwMS.
为多发性硬化症(MS)患者选择疾病修正治疗(DMT)具有挑战性。在对MS患者进行护理时,神经科医生和高级执业护士(APN)在筛查患者以启动DMT或在不同DMT之间切换、评估新DMT的安全性以及监测不良事件时,可能面临知识和信心方面的差距。医疗保健提供者需要具备更强的患者沟通技巧,以分享治疗决策并评估治疗依从性。为了更好地为教育干预提供信息,有必要更好地理解这些挑战并找出其因果关系。我们在七个国家开展了一项国际研究,以确定可能影响DMT选择以及对MS患者(pwMS)最佳护理的神经科医生和APN所面临的挑战。
这项混合方法研究包括两个并行的数据收集阶段,一个是采用半结构化访谈的定性阶段,另一个是使用在线调查的定量阶段。从加拿大、法国、德国、意大利、西班牙、英国和美国招募了神经科医生(n = 333)和APN(n = 135)。所有参与者必须在pwMS护理方面至少有两年经验,并且目前仍活跃于临床实践。
对定性和定量数据的三角分析确定了多个挑战。对于APN来说,这些挑战主要与MS诊断、在实践中纳入新药物、序贯DMT选择、治疗监测以及提供个性化护理有关。具体而言,三分之二的APN表示对2017年麦克唐纳标准没有或只有基本了解,超过一半的人表示对可用的新DMT存在知识差距(51%),并且在将它们纳入实践时存在技能差距(58%)。APN表示在治疗排序方面存在知识差距(46%),在做出排序决策方面存在技能差距(62%)。44%的APN报告在将患者目标纳入治疗建议的技能方面存在差距。对于神经科医生来说,主要挑战包括管理副作用、使护理与患者的个人目标和生活质量(QoL)保持一致。具体而言,超过三分之一的神经科医生表示对治疗失败的特征没有或只有基本了解(35%),32%的人表示没有或只有基本技能来识别治疗失败。39%的神经科医生报告在将患者的个人目标纳入治疗建议所需的技能方面没有或水平较低。此外,在与患者讨论特定MS相关主题的大多数(14项中的9项)信心项目上,根据执业年限存在显著差异。各国之间也存在显著差异。
MS诊断的复杂性以及pwMS可用DMT的多样性导致了不确定性,即使在专业医疗保健专业人员中也是如此。应通过有针对性的教育和培训来解决这些问题,以优化对pwMS的护理。