Department of Pediatrics and Izmir University of Health Sciences Tepecik Education and Reseach Hospital, İzmir, Turkey.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Izmir University of Health Sciences Tepecik Education and Reseach Hospital, İzmir, Turkey.
Breastfeed Med. 2021 Aug;16(8):635-639. doi: 10.1089/bfm.2020.0301. Epub 2021 Mar 19.
In this study, we aimed to evaluate the quality, reliability, and utility of breastfeeding videos on YouTube. We conducted a YouTube search with the keyword "breastfeeding education" and limited our search results to the first 200 videos. After exclusion criteria, 165 videos were investigated. The viewer parameters including likes, dislikes, the total number of views, comments, and source of the videos were evaluated. The educational content of the videos was evaluated with the Global Quality Score. In addition, the popularity of the videos was assessed with the video power index (VPI). Upload sources were categorized as the academic institutions and individual users. There were 134 (81.2%) videos in group 1 (poor and suboptimal quality videos) and 31 (18.8%) videos in group 2 (good and excellent quality videos). The mean number of views, likes, and comments were 96.212 ± 198.445, 241.2 ± 310.2, and 45.3 ± 67.9, respectively, in group 1, and 203.057 ± 388.722, 474.1 ± 560.6, and 63.6 ± 98, respectively, in group 2. Comparing both groups, the length of good-excellent videos was longer than poor-suboptimal videos. There were no differences between groups based on number of comments and number of dislikes. In addition, VPI values in group 2 were statistically higher than those in group 1 ( < 0.001). Only ∼18.8% of YouTube videos presenting breastfeeding education were good or excellent. YouTube videos depicting breastfeeding were a limited source for the patients.
在这项研究中,我们旨在评估 YouTube 上母乳喂养视频的质量、可靠性和实用性。我们使用关键字“母乳喂养教育”进行了 YouTube 搜索,并将搜索结果限制在前 200 个视频。排除标准后,我们调查了 165 个视频。评估了观众参数,包括喜欢、不喜欢、总观看次数、评论和视频来源。使用全球质量评分评估视频的教育内容。此外,使用视频功率指数(VPI)评估视频的受欢迎程度。上传来源分为学术机构和个人用户。第 1 组(质量差和次优视频)有 134 个(81.2%)视频,第 2 组(质量好和优视频)有 31 个(18.8%)视频。第 1 组的平均观看次数、喜欢和评论分别为 96.212±198.445、241.2±310.2 和 45.3±67.9,第 2 组分别为 203.057±388.722、474.1±560.6 和 63.6±98。比较两组,优质视频的长度长于质量差次的视频。两组之间在评论数和不喜欢数方面没有差异。此外,第 2 组的 VPI 值明显高于第 1 组(<0.001)。在呈现母乳喂养教育的 YouTube 视频中,只有约 18.8%的视频质量良好或优秀。描述母乳喂养的 YouTube 视频是患者的有限资源。