Department of Nursing Research and Evidence-Based Practice, Children's Wisconsin, Milwaukee, WI, USA.
Women, Children and Family Health Science, College of Nursing, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA.
BMC Pediatr. 2021 Mar 24;21(1):142. doi: 10.1186/s12887-021-02596-1.
Multi-sensory behavioral interventions for preterm infants have the potential to accelerate feeding, growth, and optimize developmental trajectories and increase parents' interactive engagement with their infants. However, few neonatal intensive care units (NICUs) provide evidence-based standardized early behavioral interventions as routine care. Lack of implementation is a major gap between research and clinical practice. H-HOPE, is a standardized behavioral intervention with an infant- directed component (Massage+) and a parent-directed component (four participatory guidance sessions that focus on preterm infants' behaviors and appropriate responses). H-HOPE has well documented efficacy. The purpose of this implementation study is to establish H-HOPE as the standard of care in 5 NICUs.
The study employs a Type 3 Hybrid design to simultaneously examine the implementation process and effectiveness in five NICUs. To stagger implementation across the clinical sites, we use an incomplete stepped wedge design. The five participating NICUs were purposively selected to represent different acuity levels, number of beds, locations and populations served. Our implementation strategy integrates our experience conducting H-HOPE and a well-established implementation model, the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR). The CFIR identifies influences (facilitators and barriers) that affect successful implementation within five domains: intervention characteristics, outer setting (the hospital and external events and stakeholders), inner setting (NICU), implementers' individual characteristics, and the implementation process. NICUs will use the CFIR process, which includes three phases: Planning and Engaging, Executing, and Reflecting and Evaluating. Because sustaining is a critical goal of implementation, we modify the CFIR implementation process by adding a final phase of Sustaining.
This study builds on the CFIR, adding Sustaining H-HOPE to observe what happens when sites begin to maintain implementation without outside support, and extends its use to the NICU acute care setting. Our mixed methods analysis systematically identifies key facilitators and barriers of implementation success and effectiveness across the five domains of the CFIR. Long term benefits have not yet been studied but may include substantial health and developmental outcomes for infants, more optimal parent-child relationships, reduced stress and costs for families, and substantial indirect societal benefits including reduced health care and special education costs.
ClinicalTrials.gov registration number NCT04555590 , Registered on 8/19/2020.
多感官行为干预措施可促进早产儿的喂养、生长,并优化其发育轨迹,增加父母与婴儿的互动。然而,很少有新生儿重症监护病房(NICU)将循证标准化早期行为干预措施作为常规护理提供。实施的缺乏是研究与临床实践之间的主要差距。H-HOPE 是一种标准化行为干预措施,包含婴儿导向成分(按摩+)和父母导向成分(四次关注早产儿行为和适当反应的参与性指导课程)。H-HOPE 已被充分证明有效。本实施研究旨在将 H-HOPE 确立为 5 个 NICU 的标准护理。
本研究采用 3 型混合设计,同时在 5 个 NICU 中检查实施过程和效果。为了在临床地点交错实施,我们使用不完整的分步楔形设计。参与的 5 个 NICU 是有目的地选择的,代表不同的严重程度、床位数、位置和服务人群。我们的实施策略整合了我们在进行 H-HOPE 方面的经验以及一个成熟的实施模型,即整合实施研究框架(CFIR)。CFIR 确定了影响(促进因素和障碍),这些影响因素会在五个领域内影响成功实施:干预措施的特征、外部环境(医院和外部事件及利益相关者)、内部环境(NICU)、实施者的个体特征以及实施过程。NICU 将使用 CFIR 过程,该过程包括三个阶段:计划和参与、执行以及反思和评估。由于维持是实施的关键目标,因此我们通过添加维持 H-HOPE 的最后一个阶段来修改 CFIR 实施过程。
本研究以 CFIR 为基础,增加了维持 H-HOPE,以观察当站点开始在没有外部支持的情况下维持实施时会发生什么情况,并将其应用于 NICU 急性护理环境。我们的混合方法分析系统地确定了 CFIR 五个领域内实施成功和效果的关键促进因素和障碍。长期效益尚未得到研究,但可能包括婴儿的健康和发育结果的显著改善、更理想的亲子关系、家庭压力和成本的降低以及包括减少医疗保健和特殊教育成本在内的大量间接社会效益。
ClinicalTrials.gov 注册号 NCT04555590,注册于 2020 年 8 月 19 日。