School of Economics and Management, Shanghai Maritime University, Shanghai 201306, PR China.
School of Marxism, Shanghai Maritime University, Shanghai 201306, PR China.
Waste Manag. 2021 May 1;126:163-169. doi: 10.1016/j.wasman.2021.03.010. Epub 2021 Mar 23.
Reducing the usage of plastic bags has been a pressing task for governments around the world. In China, the government also makes extensive efforts to contrast the negative effects of plastic bag usage by issuing different laws and policies. Conducting an on-site counting of bags used by consumers, this study investigates the usage of plastic bags in China and evaluates the effectiveness of these policies within both supermarkets and vegetable markets (popular markets primarily for vegetables in China). Besides, 5 different factors are investigated to learn their potential influence on the usage of plastic bags, including generation, gender, the price for plastic carrier bags, the packaging style of products, and market type. Results show a boomerang effect of the pricing policy (i.e., charging for plastic carrier bags) in China. Specifically, the policy decreases the usage of plastic carrier bags by 44%. However, the total usage of plastic bags increases, rather than decreases due to the excessive usage of free inner plastic packaging bags used as alternatives to plastic carrier bags. Old and middle-young consumers are disproportionately affected by the pricing policy and behave significantly differently in their usage of plastic bags. Loopholes in management and policies are also discussed.
减少塑料袋的使用一直是世界各国政府的紧迫任务。在中国,政府也通过发布不同的法律法规来大力应对塑料袋使用的负面影响。本研究通过对消费者使用塑料袋的现场计数,调查了中国塑料袋的使用情况,并评估了这些政策在超市和菜市场(中国主要销售蔬菜的农贸市场)中的有效性。此外,还调查了 5 个不同因素,以了解它们对塑料袋使用的潜在影响,包括代际、性别、塑料袋价格、产品包装方式和市场类型。研究结果表明,中国的定价政策(即塑料袋收费)产生了一种“回飞镖效应”。具体来说,该政策使塑料袋的使用减少了 44%。然而,由于免费内塑料袋包装的过度使用,作为塑料袋的替代品,塑料袋的总用量反而增加,而不是减少。老、中、青年消费者受到定价政策的不成比例影响,在塑料袋使用方面的行为明显不同。还讨论了管理和政策中的漏洞。