Department of Health Economics and Health Services Research, University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, 20251 Hamburg, Germany.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021 Mar 3;18(5):2491. doi: 10.3390/ijerph18052491.
A systematic review synthesizing studies examining the determinants of dental service use drawing on the (extended) Andersen model is lacking. Hence, our purpose was to fill this knowledge gap; Methods: Three established electronic databases (PubMed, PsycInfo, as well as CINAHL) were searched. Observational studies focusing on the determinants of dental service use drawing on the Andersen model were included; Results: In sum, 41 studies have been included (ten studies investigating children/adolescents and 31 studies investigating adults). Among children, particularly higher age (predisposing characteristic), higher income (enabling resource) and more oral health problems (need factor) were associated with increased dental service use. Among adults, findings are, in general, less consistent. However, it should be noted that one half of the studies found an association between increased education (predisposing characteristic) and increased dental service. In general, study quality was rather high. However, it should be noted that most studies did not report how they dealt with missing data; Conclusions: Our systematic review revealed that all components (i.e., predisposing characteristics, enabling resources and need factors) of the Andersen model tend to be associated with dental service use among children, whereas the findings are more mixed among adults. In conclusion, beyond need factors, dental service use also tend to be driven by other factors. This may indicate over-or, more likely-underuse of dental services and could enrich the inequality discussion in dental services research.
一项系统综述综合了利用(扩展的)安德森模型研究牙科服务利用决定因素的研究,但缺乏这方面的研究。因此,我们的目的是填补这一知识空白;方法:我们检索了三个已建立的电子数据库(PubMed、PsycInfo 和 CINAHL)。纳入了基于安德森模型研究牙科服务利用决定因素的观察性研究;结果:总共纳入了 41 项研究(10 项研究调查儿童/青少年,31 项研究调查成年人)。在儿童中,较高的年龄(倾向特征)、较高的收入(使能资源)和更多的口腔健康问题(需求因素)与增加牙科服务的使用有关。在成年人中,结果通常不太一致。然而,应该注意的是,有一半的研究发现,教育程度的提高(倾向特征)与牙科服务的增加之间存在关联。总的来说,研究质量相当高。然而,应该注意的是,大多数研究没有报告他们如何处理缺失数据;结论:我们的系统综述显示,安德森模型的所有组成部分(即倾向特征、使能资源和需求因素)都与儿童的牙科服务利用有关,而成年人的发现则更为复杂。总之,除了需求因素外,牙科服务的利用还可能受到其他因素的驱动。这可能表明牙科服务的过度使用或更有可能的使用不足,并丰富牙科服务研究中的不平等讨论。