School of Economics and Management, Tongji University, Shanghai 200092, China.
Department of Building and Real Estate, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong 999077, China.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021 Mar 30;18(7):3594. doi: 10.3390/ijerph18073594.
The construction industry suffers from poor safety performance caused by the joint effect of insufficient safety investment by contractors and inefficient safety supervision by the government because of the information gap between the two sides. The present study aims to put forward a new pathway to improve safety investment supervision efficiency and analyze the decision-making interactions of stakeholders under this new pathway. For this purpose, this study establishes a safety investment information system to eliminate the information gap between the government and contractors for construction projects in China and further develops a dynamic safety investment supervision mechanism based on this. Evolutionary game theory is used to describe the decision-making interactions among stakeholders under the current static supervision mechanism and the dynamic supervision mechanism proposed in this research. Moreover, system dynamics is adopted to simulate the evolutionary game process and analyze the supervision effect and equilibrium state of different supervision mechanisms. The results reveal that the proposed safety investment information system could facilitate the transition of the supervision mode from static to dynamic; the evolutionarily stable strategy does not exist in the current static penalty scenario; and the dynamic supervision mechanism that correlates penalties with contractors' unlawful behavior probability can restrain the fluctuation of the evolutionary game model effectively and the players' strategy choices gradually stabilize in the equilibrium state. The results validate the effectiveness of the proposed dynamic supervision mechanism in improving supervision efficiency. This study not only contributes to the literature on safety supervision policy-making but also helps to improve supervision efficiency in practice.
建筑行业的安全绩效不佳,这是由于承包商安全投入不足和政府安全监管效率低下共同作用的结果,而这种低效率是由于双方之间存在信息差距。本研究旨在提出一种新的途径来提高安全投资监管效率,并分析在这种新途径下利益相关者的决策互动。为此,本研究建立了一个安全投资信息系统,以消除中国建筑项目中政府和承包商之间的信息差距,并在此基础上进一步开发了一个基于动态的安全投资监管机制。本研究采用演化博弈理论来描述现行静态监管机制和本文提出的动态监管机制下的利益相关者的决策互动。此外,还采用系统动力学来模拟不同监管机制的演化博弈过程,并分析不同监管机制的监管效果和均衡状态。结果表明,所提出的安全投资信息系统可以促进监管模式从静态向动态的转变;现行静态罚款情景下不存在演化稳定策略;与承包商违法行为概率相关联的动态监管机制可以有效抑制演化博弈模型的波动,使参与者的策略选择在均衡状态下逐渐稳定。研究结果验证了所提出的动态监管机制在提高监管效率方面的有效性。本研究不仅为安全监管政策制定的文献做出了贡献,也有助于提高实践中的监管效率。