Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA.
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Nemours/Alfred I. duPont Hospital for Children, Wilmington, DE.
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2021 May 1;46(9):579-587. doi: 10.1097/BRS.0000000000003795.
Retrospective descriptive, multicenter study.
The aim of this study was to predict the three-dimensional (3D) radiographic outcomes of the spinal surgery in a cohort of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) as a function preoperative spinal parameters and surgeon modifiable factors.
Current guidelines for posterior spinal fusion surgery (PSF) in AIS patients are based on two-dimensional classification of the spinal curves. Despite the high success rate, the prediction of the 3D spinal alignment at the follow-ups remains inconclusive. A data-driven surgical decision-making method that determines the combination of the surgical procedures and preoperative patient specific parameters that leads to a specific 3D global spinal alignment outcomes at the follow-ups can lessen the burden of surgical planning and improve patient satisfaction by setting expectations prior to surgery.
A dataset of 371 AIS patients who underwent a PSF with two-year follow-up were included. Demographics, 2D radiographic spinal and pelvic measurements, clinical measurements of the trunk shape, and the surgical procedures were collected prospectively. A previously developed classification of the preoperative global 3D spinal alignment was used as an additional predictor. The 3D spinal alignment (vertebral positions and rotations) at two-year follow-up was used as the predicted outcome. An ensemble learner was used to predict the 3D spinal alignment at two-year follow-up as a function of the preoperative parameters with and without considering the surgeon modifiable factors.
The preoperative and surgical factors predicted three clusters of 3D surgical outcomes with an accuracy of 75%. The prediction accuracy decreased to 64% when only preoperative factors, without the surgical factors, were used in the model. Predictor importance analysis determined that preoperative distal junctional kyphosis, pelvic sagittal parameters, end-instrumented vertebra (EIV) angulation and translation, and the preoperative 3D clusters are the most important patient-specific predictors of the outcomes. Three surgical factors, upper and lower instrumented vertebrae, and the operating surgeon, were important surgical predictors. The role of surgeon in achieving a certain outcome clusters for specific ranges of preoperative T10-L2 kyphosis, EIV angulation and translation, thoracic and lumbar flexibilities, and patient's height was significant.
Both preoperative patient-specific and surgeon modifiable parameters predicted the 3D global spinal alignment at two-year post PSF. Surgeon was determined as a predictor of the outcomes despite including 20 factors in the analysis that described the surgical moves. Methods to quantify the differences between the implemented surgeon modifiable factors are essential to improve outcome prediction in AIS spinal surgery.Level of Evidence: 3.
回顾性描述性、多中心研究。
本研究旨在预测一组青少年特发性脊柱侧凸(AIS)脊柱手术的三维(3D)放射学结果,作为术前脊柱参数和外科医生可修改因素的函数。
目前,AIS 患者后路脊柱融合术(PSF)的指南基于脊柱曲线的二维分类。尽管成功率很高,但在随访中对 3D 脊柱排列的预测仍不确定。一种数据驱动的手术决策方法,可以确定手术程序和术前患者特定参数的组合,从而在随访时得出特定的 3D 整体脊柱排列结果,可以减轻手术规划的负担,并通过在手术前设定预期来提高患者满意度。
纳入了 371 例接受 PSF 并进行两年随访的 AIS 患者。前瞻性收集人口统计学资料、2D 放射学脊柱和骨盆测量、躯干形状的临床测量以及手术程序。使用先前开发的术前全球 3D 脊柱排列分类作为附加预测因子。将两年随访时的 3D 脊柱排列(椎体位置和旋转)作为预测结果。使用集成学习器根据术前参数预测两年随访时的 3D 脊柱排列,同时考虑和不考虑外科医生可修改的因素。
术前和手术因素预测了 3D 手术结果的三个聚类,准确率为 75%。当模型中仅使用术前因素而不使用手术因素时,预测准确性下降至 64%。预测因子重要性分析确定,术前远端交界性后凸、骨盆矢状参数、终末置钉椎(EIV)角度和位移以及术前 3D 聚类是结果的最重要患者特异性预测因子。三个手术因素,上、下置钉椎以及手术医生,是重要的手术预测因子。尽管在分析中包括了 20 个描述手术动作的因素,但医生在实现特定术前 T10-L2 后凸、EIV 角度和位移、胸腰椎柔韧性以及患者身高范围内特定结果聚类方面的作用具有统计学意义。
术前患者特异性和外科医生可修改参数均可预测 PSF 后两年的 3D 整体脊柱排列。尽管在分析中包括了 20 个描述手术动作的因素,但外科医生被确定为结果的预测因子。量化实施的外科医生可修改因素之间差异的方法对于提高 AIS 脊柱手术的结果预测至关重要。
3 级