Spiessberger Alexander, Dietz Nicholas, Gruter Basil, Virojanapa Justin
Department of Neurosurgery, Hofstra School of Medicine, North Shore University Hospital, Manhasset, NY, USA.
Department of Neurosurgery, University of Louisville, Louisville, KY, USA.
J Craniovertebr Junction Spine. 2020 Oct-Dec;11(4):287-292. doi: 10.4103/jcvjs.JCVJS_166_20. Epub 2020 Nov 26.
Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS) predisposes to craniocervical instability (CCI) with resulting cranial settling and cervicomedullary syndrome due to ligamentous laxity. This study investigates possible differences in radiographic outcomes and operative complication rate between two surgical techniques in patients with EDS and CCI undergoing craniocervical fusion (CCF): occipital bone (OB) versus occipital condyle (OC) fixation.
A retrospective search of the institutional operative database between January 07, 2017, and December 31, 2019, was conducted to identify EDS patients who underwent CCF with either OB (Group OB) or OC (Group OC) fixation. For each patient, pre- and post-operative radiographic measurements and operative complications were extracted and compared between groups (OB vs. OC): pB-C2, clivoaxial angle (CXA), tonsillar descent, C2C7 sagittal Cobb angle, C2 long axis, and operative complications.
Of a total of 26 patients, 13 underwent OV and 13 underwent OC fixation. Eighty-five percent of the patients underwent OC underwent fusion from occiput to C2, while the remaining 15% fusion from occiput to C3. Radiographic outcome in the OC versus OB group was preoperative measurements were similar between OC and OB group: pB-C2 8.8 mm (1.5, 6-11) versus 8.3 mm (1.7, 4-9.6), = 0.43; CXA 128.2° (5.4, 122-136) versus 131.9° (6.8,122-141), = 0.41; tonsillar descent 6.2 mm (4.8, 0-15) versus 2.9 mm (3.4, 0-8), = 0.05; C2 long axis 75.2° (6.7, 58-85) versus 67.2° (21.4, 1-80), = 0.21; postoperative change of CXA + 14.4° (8.8, 0-30) versus 16.2° (12.4, -4-38), = 0.43; change of pB-C2 - 2.6 mm (1.8, --5.3 to 0) versus - 1.2 mm (4, -4.6-8), = 0.26; and postoperative C2C7 sagittal Cobb angle - 2.6° (19.5, -43-39) versus - 2.6° (11.4, -21-12). Operative complications were seen in 1 out of 13 patients (8%) versus 2 out of 13 patients (16%), = 1.
In EDS, patients with CCI undergoing CCF radiographic and clinical outcome were similar between those with OC versus OB fixation. Both techniques resulted in sufficient correction of pB-C2 and CXA measurements with a low complication rate.
埃勒斯-当洛综合征(EDS)因韧带松弛易导致颅颈交界区不稳定(CCI),进而引起颅骨沉降和颈髓综合征。本研究调查了接受颅颈融合术(CCF)的EDS合并CCI患者,在两种手术技术(枕骨(OB)固定与枕髁(OC)固定)之间,影像学结果和手术并发症发生率的可能差异。
对2017年1月7日至2019年12月31日期间机构手术数据库进行回顾性检索,以确定接受OB固定(OB组)或OC固定(OC组)的CCF的EDS患者。对于每位患者,提取术前和术后的影像学测量数据及手术并发症,并在两组(OB组与OC组)之间进行比较:枕骨大孔前缘至C2距离(pB-C2)、斜坡-枢椎角(CXA)、扁桃体下移、C2-C7矢状面Cobb角、C2长轴以及手术并发症。
总共26例患者中,13例行OB固定,13例行OC固定。接受OC固定的患者中,85%从枕骨至C2融合,其余15%从枕骨至C3融合。OC组与OB组的影像学结果:术前测量值在两组间相似:pB-C2为8.8毫米(1.5,6 - 11)对8.3毫米(1.7,4 - 9.6),P = 0.43;CXA为128.2°(5.4,122 - 136)对131.9°(6.8,122 - 141),P = 0.41;扁桃体下移为6.2毫米(4.8,0 - 15)对2.9毫米(3.4,0 - 8),P = 0.05;C2长轴为75.2°(6.7,58 - 85)对67.2°(21.4,1 - 80),P = 0.21;术后CXA变化为 + 14.4°(8.8,0 - 30)对16.2°(12.4, - 4 - 38),P = 0.43;pB-C2变化为 - 2.6毫米(1.8, - 5.3至0)对 - 1.2毫米(4, - 4.6 - 8),P = 0.26;术后C2-C7矢状面Cobb角为 - 2.6°(19.5, - 43 - 39)对 - 2.6°(11.4, - 21 - 12)。手术并发症在13例患者中的1例(8%)与13例患者中的2例(16%)出现,P = 1。
在EDS中,接受CCF的CCI患者,OC固定与OB固定的影像学和临床结果相似。两种技术均能充分矫正pB-C2和CXA测量值,且并发症发生率低。