Department of Food and Human Nutritional Sciences, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, MB, Canada.
Department of Nutrition and Food Services, Health Sciences Centre, Winnipeg, MB, Canada.
Plant Foods Hum Nutr. 2021 Jun;76(2):196-202. doi: 10.1007/s11130-021-00889-5. Epub 2021 Apr 6.
Data has indicated that gluten-free (GF) foods are more expensive and have lower nutritional value than their gluten-containing (GC) counterparts. The aim of the present study was to compare the cost and nutrient content between GF and GC staple foods and determine whether the number and price of GF staple foods differed based on type of store or location within Winnipeg, Canada. Twelve grocery stores (2 chain stores/quadrant;1 local store/quadrant) in the four quadrants (northwest, northeast, southwest, southeast) of Winnipeg were visited to identify GF staple products (bread, flour, cereal, pasta) along with a GC comparator. A total of 819 GF products along with GC comparators were identified. The median cost of GF products ($1.50/100 g) was 131 % greater than that of GC ($0.65/100 g) (p < 0.0001). The greatest difference in cost was between GF and GC flour, with the least difference occurring between GF and GC cereal. GF products were 58, 36 and 100 % lower in iron, protein and saturated fat (p < 0.0001) than their GC comparators, respectively. The number of GF staple products was 370 % higher (p < 0.007) at chain stores than at local stores, whereas store location did not significantly affect the number of GF products available. The greatest difference in number of different GF foods based on store type was for cereals, with the least being for flours. These results confirm that GF staple foods are more expensive and have lower nutritional value (mainly due to lower iron and protein content) compared to GC foods.
数据表明,无麸质(GF)食品比含麸质(GC)食品更昂贵,营养价值更低。本研究旨在比较 GF 和 GC 主食的成本和营养成分,并确定 GF 主食的数量和价格是否因商店类型或温尼伯市的位置而异。研究人员走访了温尼伯市四个象限(西北、东北、西南、东南)的 12 家杂货店(2 家连锁店/象限;1 家当地商店/象限),以确定 GF 主食产品(面包、面粉、谷物、意大利面)以及 GC 比较产品。共确定了 819 种 GF 产品和 GC 比较产品。GF 产品的中位数成本(1.50 美元/100 克)比 GC 产品(0.65 美元/100 克)高 131%(p<0.0001)。成本差异最大的是 GF 和 GC 面粉之间,而 GF 和 GC 谷物之间的差异最小。GF 产品的铁、蛋白质和饱和脂肪含量分别比其 GC 比较产品低 58%、36%和 100%(p<0.0001)。在连锁商店,GF 主食产品的数量比当地商店高 370%(p<0.007),而商店位置对 GF 产品的数量没有显著影响。根据商店类型,GF 食品数量的差异最大的是谷物,差异最小的是面粉。这些结果证实,与 GC 食品相比,GF 主食更昂贵,营养价值更低(主要是由于铁和蛋白质含量较低)。