Kato Yuichi, Chiba Rie, Shimazu Akihito
Kobe University.
Keio University.
Workplace Health Saf. 2021 Jul;69(7):323-342. doi: 10.1177/21650799211002471. Epub 2021 Apr 13.
Work engagement (WE) is defined as a positive, fulfilling, and work-related state of mind. Enhancing WE leads to positive outcomes in both individuals and organizations. Although cultural factors may influence the antecedents and outcomes of WE, no reviews summarized these factors among nurses, mainly in Asia. This review aimed to identify the antecedents and outcomes of WE among nurses in Japan. This may offer novel insights into the influencing factors on WE.
A literature search was conducted using six data sources: PubMed, Cumulative Index of Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL), PsycINFO, Business Source Premier, Ichushi-Web, and CiNii. A total of 38 studies met the inclusion criteria. Studies that included registered nurses and/or midwives at hospitals or facilities were included in this review. The antecedents and outcomes were classified into four themes based on the job demands-resources model (JD-R model).
Many variables in three components of the JD-R model (i.e., job resources, personal resources, and favorable outcomes) exhibited positive relationships with WE as theorized. Many other variables in job demands demonstrated negative relationships with WE as hypothesized. Many factors that were identified in this review were consistent with the JD-R model. The model in turn was found to be applicable among nurses. The antecedents and outcomes in this review were similar to those in previous studies in Western countries, while this review also revealed teamwork nursing as a possible antecedent of WE, which has not previously been reported.
CONCLUSION/APPLICATION TO PRACTICE: Improving job resources (e.g., teamwork nursing) and personal resources may effectively enhance WE among Japanese nurses.
工作投入(WE)被定义为一种积极、充实且与工作相关的心理状态。提高工作投入会给个人和组织带来积极的结果。尽管文化因素可能会影响工作投入的前因和后果,但尚无综述总结护士群体(主要是亚洲护士)中的这些因素。本综述旨在确定日本护士工作投入的前因和后果。这可能为影响工作投入的因素提供新的见解。
使用六个数据源进行文献检索:PubMed、护理及相关健康文献累积索引(CINAHL)、心理学文摘数据库(PsycINFO)、商业资源数据库全文版(Business Source Premier)、医学中央杂志网络版(Ichushi-Web)和CiNii。共有38项研究符合纳入标准。本综述纳入了涉及医院或机构中注册护士和/或助产士的研究。根据工作要求-资源模型(JD-R模型),将前因和后果分为四个主题。
JD-R模型的三个组成部分(即工作资源、个人资源和积极结果)中的许多变量如理论假设的那样与工作投入呈正相关。工作要求中的许多其他变量如假设的那样与工作投入呈负相关。本综述中确定的许多因素与JD-R模型一致。反过来,该模型被发现适用于护士群体。本综述中的前因和后果与西方国家先前研究中的相似,同时本综述还揭示团队协作护理可能是工作投入的一个前因,这在以前未曾报道过。
结论/对实践的应用:改善工作资源(如团队协作护理)和个人资源可能有效提高日本护士的工作投入。