van Geen Alexander, Yao Yuling, Ellis Tyler, Gelman Andrew
Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory Columbia University Palisades NY USA.
Department of Statistics Columbia University New York, NY USA.
Geohealth. 2020 Aug 21;4(8):e2020GH000279. doi: 10.1029/2020GH000279. eCollection 2020 Aug.
The roof and spire of Notre-Dame cathedral in Paris that caught fire and collapsed on 15 April 2019 were covered with 460 t of lead (Pb). Government reports documented Pb deposition immediately downwind of the cathedral and a twentyfold increase in airborne Pb concentrations at a distance of 50 km in the aftermath. For this study, we collected 100 samples of surface soil from tree pits, parks, and other sites in all directions within 1 km of the cathedral. Concentrations of Pb measured by X-ray fluorescence range from 30 to 9,000 mg/kg across the area, with a higher proportion of elevated concentrations to the northwest of the cathedral, in the direction of the wind prevailing during the fire. By integrating these observations with a Gaussian process regression model, we estimate that the average concentration of Pb in surface soil downwind of the cathedral is 430 (95% interval, 300-590) mg/kg, nearly double the average Pb concentration in the other directions of 240 (95% interval, 170-320) mg/kg. The difference corresponds to an integrated excess Pb inventory within a 1 km radius of 1.0 (95% interval, 0.5-1.5) t, about 0.2% of all the Pb covering the roof and spire. This is over 6 times the estimated amount of Pb deposited downwind 1-50 km from the cathedral. To what extent the concentrated fallout within 1 km documented here temporarily exposed the downwind population to Pb is difficult to confirm independently because too few soil, dust, and blood samples were collected immediately after the fire.
2019年4月15日起火并坍塌的巴黎圣母院大教堂的屋顶和尖顶覆盖着460吨铅(Pb)。政府报告记录了大教堂下风向的铅沉积情况,火灾发生后,在50公里处空气中铅浓度增加了20倍。在本研究中,我们从大教堂1公里范围内各个方向的树坑、公园和其他地点采集了100份表层土壤样本。通过X射线荧光测定的铅浓度在该区域范围内为30至9000毫克/千克,在大教堂西北方向(火灾期间盛行风的方向),浓度升高的比例更高。通过将这些观测结果与高斯过程回归模型相结合,我们估计大教堂下风向表层土壤中铅的平均浓度为430(95%区间,300 - 590)毫克/千克,几乎是其他方向平均铅浓度240(95%区间,170 - 320)毫克/千克的两倍。这种差异相当于在1公里半径范围内累计过量铅存量为1.0(95%区间,0.5 - 1.5)吨,约占覆盖屋顶和尖顶所有铅的0.2%。这是大教堂下风向1 - 50公里处估计铅沉积量的6倍多。由于火灾后立即采集的土壤、灰尘和血液样本太少,难以独立确认此处记录的1公里范围内的集中沉降在多大程度上使下风向人群暂时暴露于铅中。