Lorensia Amelia, Budiono Ryanto, Suryadinata Rivan Virlando, Tiarasari Navy
Department of Clinical Pharmacy-Community, Faculty of Pharmacy, Universitas Surabaya, Jl. Raya Kalirungkut, Surabaya.
Department of Public Health, Faculty of Medicine, Universitas Surabaya, Jl. Raya Kalirungkut, Surabaya.
J Public Health Res. 2021 Apr 14;10(2):2159. doi: 10.4081/jphr.2021.2159.
The consumption of EPA (Eicosapentaenoic acid), and DHA (docosahexaenoic acid), from fish oil, in the long run, has been observed to have a positive impact on patients with coronary heart disease. Fish oil products, with so much EPA and DHA content are available, and have very variable prices. Therefore, as a therapy to be used for long-term treatment, the cost factor is to be considered.
This study analyzed the content of EPA and DHA, using GC-MS. The sample to be analyzed was the fish oil that has the lowest price (Product A1), and that of the highest (Product A2). Furthermore, the macroscopic analysis was performed, by observing the physical form including organoleptic and qualitative tests, by reading the fragments identified by EPA and DHA.
Clinical trials were conducted on patients (about 46 people), with risk factors and dyslipidemia. Product A1 showed EPA at tR= 15.574 min (relative%= 88.49%, similarity= 95%), and DHA at tR= 21.714 min (relative%= 88.92%, similarity= 93%). Product A2 showed EPA at tR= 28.719 min (relative%= 22.58%, similarity= 89%), and DHA at tR= 32.327 min (relative%= 22.87%, similarity= 90%), which meant that both had EPA and DHA contents, in accordance with their labels. Both products were confirmed to reduce total cholesterol in 4weeks (p=0.000, p= 0.000), with no significant difference in their effectiveness (p=0.652).
The results showed that both the A1 and A2 products, had the EPA and DHA contents in accordance with their respective labels. However, with the A2 product having a percentage relatively higher than that of the A1 brand, both are equally very effective.
长期以来,人们观察到食用鱼油中的二十碳五烯酸(EPA)和二十二碳六烯酸(DHA)对冠心病患者有积极影响。市面上有很多富含EPA和DHA的鱼油产品,价格差异很大。因此,作为一种长期治疗手段,成本因素需要考虑。
本研究采用气相色谱 - 质谱联用(GC - MS)分析EPA和DHA的含量。待分析的样品是价格最低的鱼油(产品A1)和价格最高的鱼油(产品A2)。此外,通过观察包括感官和定性测试在内的物理形态,读取由EPA和DHA鉴定的片段进行宏观分析。
对有危险因素和血脂异常的患者(约46人)进行了临床试验。产品A1在tR = 15.574分钟时显示EPA(相对含量 = 88.49%,相似度 = 95%),在tR = 21.714分钟时显示DHA(相对含量 = 88.92%,相似度 = 93%)。产品A2在tR = 28.719分钟时显示EPA(相对含量 = 22.58%,相似度 = 89%),在tR = 32.327分钟时显示DHA(相对含量 = 22.87%,相似度 = 90%),这意味着两者的EPA和DHA含量均符合其标签标注。两种产品均在4周内证实可降低总胆固醇(p = 0.000,p = 0.000),其有效性无显著差异(p = 0.652)。
结果表明,A1和A2产品的EPA和DHA含量均符合各自标签标注。然而,A2产品的含量百分比相对高于A1品牌,两者的效果同样显著。