Sonoda Kento, Nakaishi Lindsay, Salter Cynthia
Department of Family Medicine, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center Shadyside, Pittsburgh, PA.
University of Pittsburgh Graduate School of Public Health, Pittsburgh, PA.
PRiMER. 2021 Feb 4;5:8. doi: 10.22454/PRiMER.2021.678175. eCollection 2021.
Handoff miscommunications are a leading cause of medical errors. A structured handoff is an effective communication tool. We introduced the I-PASS Handoff Bundle for resident sign-out in the inpatient setting. We aimed to reduce preventable adverse events and unexpected floor calls while also improving residents' confidence and preparedness to care for patients overnight.
We conducted an observational study at a single-site family medicine residency between April 2019 and March 2020. Residents received trainings in the I-PASS standardized handoff through didactic lectures and on-the-job sessions in September and November 2019. We evaluated the effectiveness of the I-PASS Handoff Bundle by comparing pre- and postimplementation data including number of medical errors and unexpected floor calls, along with residents' reported levels of preparedness and confidence to care for patients overnight.
Prior to the I-PASS intervention, more than half of resident surveys included at least one unexpected floor call whereas postintervention about one-third of resident surveys included unexpected floor calls (<.05). However, the intervention did not significantly affect residents' confidence level in caring for patients overnight and residents' rating of the usefulness of anticipatory guidance for managing night floor calls. We did not identify any medical errors related to communication issues at patient handoff within the family medicine service.
I-PASS intervention significantly reduced unexpected floor calls. However, the intervention did not improve residents' reported confidence and preparedness to care for patients overnight.
交接班沟通失误是医疗差错的主要原因之一。结构化交接班是一种有效的沟通工具。我们在住院环境中引入了I-PASS交接班综合方案用于住院医师交班。我们旨在减少可预防的不良事件和意外的病房呼叫,同时提高住院医师夜间护理患者的信心和准备程度。
我们于2019年4月至2020年3月在一家单站点家庭医学住院医师培训项目中进行了一项观察性研究。住院医师于2019年9月和11月通过理论讲座和在职培训接受了I-PASS标准化交接班培训。我们通过比较实施前后的数据,包括医疗差错和意外病房呼叫的数量,以及住院医师报告的夜间护理患者的准备程度和信心水平,来评估I-PASS交接班综合方案的有效性。
在I-PASS干预之前,超过一半的住院医师调查至少包含一次意外病房呼叫;而干预后,约三分之一的住院医师调查包含意外病房呼叫(<.05)。然而,该干预并未显著影响住院医师夜间护理患者的信心水平,以及住院医师对管理夜间病房呼叫的预前指导有用性的评分。我们未发现家庭医学服务中与患者交接班时沟通问题相关的任何医疗差错。
I-PASS干预显著减少了意外病房呼叫。然而,该干预并未提高住院医师报告的夜间护理患者的信心和准备程度。