Neuroethics Canada, Division of Neurology, Department of Medicine, University of British Columbia, 2211 Wesbrook Mall, Koerner S124, Vancouver, British Columbia, V6T 2B5, Canada.
Syst Rev. 2021 Apr 19;10(1):115. doi: 10.1186/s13643-021-01664-y.
Appropriate search strategies are essential to ensure the integrity and reproducibility of systematic and scoping reviews, as researchers seek to capture as many relevant resources as possible. In the case of Indigenous health reviews, researchers are met with the special challenge of creating a search strategy that can encompass this large, diverse population group with no universally agreed upon identification criteria.
With an aim to promote improved review methodologies that uphold standards of justice, autonomy, and equity for Indigenous peoples and other heterogeneous populations, we describe critical gaps and approaches to close them. We report organizational and transparency issues around how Indigenous populations are indexed in several major databases, and draw on examples of published reviews and protocols to demonstrate the challenges inherent to creating a comprehensive search strategy.
The conduct and communication of results from health literature research on global Indigenous populations are compromised by challenges of methodology that are rooted in the complexities inherent to defining Indigenous peoples. These challenges must be urgently addressed to improve this important field of inquiry moving forward.
适当的搜索策略对于确保系统评价和范围综述的完整性和可重复性至关重要,因为研究人员力求尽可能多地获取相关资源。在原住民健康综述的情况下,研究人员面临着一个特殊的挑战,即创建一个能够涵盖这个庞大而多样化的人群的搜索策略,但这个人群没有普遍同意的识别标准。
为了促进提高符合原住民和其他异质人群正义、自治和公平标准的审查方法,我们描述了关键差距,并提出了弥补这些差距的方法。我们报告了几个主要数据库中原住民人群索引的组织和透明度问题,并借鉴了已发表的综述和方案示例,展示了创建全面搜索策略所固有的挑战。
全球原住民人口健康文献研究的结果的实施和交流受到了方法上的挑战的影响,这些挑战源于定义原住民人群所固有的复杂性。必须紧急解决这些挑战,以提高这一重要研究领域的水平。