From the Rafik Hariri University Hospital, Bir Hassan, Beirut, Lebanon.
Exp Clin Transplant. 2021 Jul;19(7):627-634. doi: 10.6002/ect.2021.0056. Epub 2021 Mar 31.
One year has elapsed since a team of Chinese scientists reported the first case of COVID-19 in Wuhan, China on January 8, 2020, after sequencing the first viral genetic material. Since then, many vaccines were rushed into testing, bypassing animal experimentations, with more than 200 pharma companies in different countries declaring the development of different vaccines, each with their own strategy for generating immunity, despite the arguments of many infectious disease experts that 18 months for a first vaccine is an incredibly aggressive schedule because it takes an average of 10 years to develop a vaccine. Ten vaccine candidates have already entered phase 3 clinical trials in humans. These vaccines rely on different types of technology, the most innovative of which use the genetic material messenger RNA. Many provocative questions and genuine concerns have been raised, such as short durations of efficacy and safety follow-ups, lack of identified correlates of protection, morbidity and mortality cases reported shortly after vaccination, uncertainties regarding the risk of enhanced disease on exposure to the virus in the long-term, the possibility of viral transmission after vaccination, the reported reduced efficacies of these vaccines against new variants, the efficacy and safety of these vaccines in the previously excluded subgroups (such as children, pregnant women, the frail elderly high-risk population, and immunocompromised individuals), the unknown risk of immunogenicity-induced autoimmune diseases, cancer and chronic inflammation, the risk of genome transformation (mainly in the presence of reverse transcriptase), and finally the potential coercion that may be imposed by either public or private sectors on citizens to receive the vaccine. Many plausible questions are apparent, with no clear and convincing answers.
自 2020 年 1 月 8 日中国科学家报告在中国武汉的第一例 COVID-19 病例以来,已经过去了一年,当时他们对第一种病毒遗传物质进行了测序。此后,许多疫苗被匆忙投入测试,绕过了动物实验,有 200 多家不同国家的制药公司宣布开发不同的疫苗,每家公司都有自己的产生免疫力的策略,尽管许多传染病专家认为,18 个月内开发出第一种疫苗是一个非常激进的时间表,因为开发一种疫苗平均需要 10 年时间。已经有 10 种候选疫苗进入了人体 3 期临床试验。这些疫苗依赖于不同类型的技术,其中最具创新性的是使用遗传物质信使 RNA。已经提出了许多具有挑衅性的问题和真正的担忧,例如疗效和安全性随访时间短、缺乏明确的保护相关性、接种后不久报告的发病率和死亡率病例、长期接触病毒时对疾病加重风险的不确定性、接种后病毒传播的可能性、这些疫苗对新变体的效力降低、这些疫苗在以前被排除的亚组(如儿童、孕妇、体弱的老年人高危人群和免疫功能低下的个体)中的疗效和安全性、免疫原性诱导自身免疫性疾病、癌症和慢性炎症的未知风险、基因组转化的风险(主要在存在逆转录酶的情况下),最后是公共部门或私营部门可能对公民接种疫苗施加的潜在强制。有许多看似合理的问题,但没有明确和令人信服的答案。