Kumar Priya, Gruzd Anatoliy, Mai Philip
Ryerson University, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Am Behav Sci. 2021 May;65(5):689-711. doi: 10.1177/0002764221989777. Epub 2021 Jan 29.
The study applies and expands the routine activity theory to examine the dynamics of online harassment and violence against women on Twitter in India. We collected 931,363 public tweets (original posts and replies) over a period of 1 month that mentioned at least one of 101 influential women in India. By undertaking both manual and automated text analysis of "hateful" tweets, we identified three broad types of violence experienced by women of influence on Twitter: dismissive insults, ethnoreligious slurs, and gendered sexual harassment. The analysis also revealed different types of individually motivated offenders: "news junkies," "Bollywood fanatics," and "lone-wolves", who do not characteristically engage in direct targeted attacks against a single person. Finally, we question the effectiveness of Twitter's form of "guardianship" against online violence against women, as we found that a year after our initial data collection in 2017, only 22% of hostile posts with explicit forms of harassment have been deleted. We conclude that in the social media age, online and offline public spheres overlap and intertwine, requiring improved regulatory approaches, policies, and moderation tools of "capable" guardianship that empower women to actively participate in public life.
该研究应用并拓展了日常活动理论,以审视印度推特上针对女性的网络骚扰与暴力行为的动态情况。我们在1个月的时间里收集了931,363条公开推文(原创帖子及回复),这些推文提及了印度101位有影响力的女性中的至少一位。通过对“仇恨性”推文进行人工和自动文本分析,我们识别出了有影响力的女性在推特上遭遇的三种主要暴力类型:轻蔑侮辱、族裔宗教诋毁以及性别针对性骚扰。分析还揭示了不同类型的个人动机型冒犯者:“新闻迷”“宝莱坞狂热分子”和“独狼”,他们通常不会对单一对象进行直接的针对性攻击。最后,我们对推特针对女性网络暴力的“监护”形式的有效性提出质疑,因为我们发现,在2017年我们首次收集数据一年后,只有22%带有明确骚扰形式的恶意帖子被删除。我们得出结论,在社交媒体时代,线上和线下公共领域相互重叠交织,需要改进监管方法、政策以及“有效”监护的审核工具,以赋予女性积极参与公共生活的权力。