Hayat Ali Asghar, Keshavarzi Mohmmad Hasan, Zare Soolmaz, Bazrafcan Leila, Rezaee Rita, Faghihi Seyed Aliakbar, Amini Mitra, Kojuri Javad
Clinical Education Research Center, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran.
BMC Med Educ. 2021 Apr 29;21(1):247. doi: 10.1186/s12909-021-02682-z.
Since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, many higher education and health centers have faced challenges. Educational leaders have tried to manage the new situation, but the human infrastructure was not ready for such an event. This study aims to explain the challenges and opportunities of the COVID-19 pandemic for medical education.
This qualitative study used conventional content analysis to collect data from face-to-face and semi-structured interviews. The interviews continued until data saturation was reached. The participants were 12 students and 14 faculty members at Shiraz University of Medical Sciences. To ensure data rigor, we used member checks, peer checks and an external observer.
Three main categories and 15 subcategories were extracted. The findings showed that four subcategories, e.g. perception on feasibility of e-learning, standardizing of e-learning, dedicated teaching, and networking and interdisciplinary collaborations, affected the development of medical e-learning. The main opportunities from the COVID-19 pandemic for medical education were classified into five subcategories: attitudes to e-learning and adaptability, preventing students' separation from the educational environment, documentation and monitoring education, take control of own learning, and increasing perceived usefulness. The main challenges were divided into four subcategories, e.g. noncompliance with virtual classroom etiquette, inadequate interactions, time limitations, and infrastructure defects and problems. Finally, participants believed that methods of evaluation in e-learning were more suitable for diagnosis and formative evaluations. Generally, two subcategories were extracted, e.g. formative and summative.
Medical schools have necessarily moved towards e-learning to compensate for the interruption in classroom education, such that traditional classes have been replaced with e-learning. These rapid, extensive changes in teaching and learning approaches have consequences for medical schools.
自新冠疫情爆发以来,许多高等教育机构和健康中心都面临着挑战。教育领导者试图应对新形势,但人力基础设施并未为此类事件做好准备。本研究旨在阐释新冠疫情给医学教育带来的挑战与机遇。
本定性研究采用常规内容分析法,通过面对面和半结构化访谈收集数据。访谈持续进行直至达到数据饱和。参与者为设拉子医科大学的12名学生和14名教职员工。为确保数据严谨性,我们采用了成员核对、同行核对和外部观察员的方法。
提取出三个主要类别和15个子类别。研究结果表明,四个子类别,即对电子学习可行性的认知、电子学习的标准化、专门教学以及网络与跨学科合作,影响了医学电子学习的发展。新冠疫情给医学教育带来的主要机遇被分为五个子类别:对电子学习的态度与适应性、防止学生与教育环境脱节、教育记录与监测、自主掌控学习以及提高感知有用性。主要挑战分为四个子类别,即不遵守虚拟课堂礼仪、互动不足、时间限制以及基础设施缺陷与问题。最后,参与者认为电子学习中的评估方法更适合诊断性评估和形成性评估。总体而言,提取出两个子类别,即形成性评估和总结性评估。
医学院校必然要转向电子学习以弥补课堂教育的中断,传统课程已被电子学习所取代。教学方法的这些迅速而广泛的变化给医学院校带来了影响。