From the Kinesiology and Integrative Physiology, Hanover College, Hanover, Indiana (DEJ, WDT); and Implementation Science, Wake Forest School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, North Carolina (JBM).
Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 2022 Mar 1;101(3):250-254. doi: 10.1097/PHM.0000000000001782.
Head trauma experienced in contact football is a growing health concern, but limited research has been conducted to assess associations between head trauma exposure and long-term concussion-related symptoms among former college football players.
We surveyed 275 former college football players who were at least 10 yrs after competition to determine the association between head trauma exposure and concussion-related symptoms later in life. Respondents provided data on their youth, high school and college playing experience, undiagnosed head injury, diagnosed concussions, and eight concussion-related symptoms. A Poisson regression was conducted to examine the association between playing experience and reported head trauma with reported symptom count, and significance was set at P ≤ 0.05.
Few participants reported diagnosed concussions in college (17.5%), but a large number reported undiagnosed football-related head injuries (68.8%) that might have resulted in a concussion. A few participants (40.7%) reported concussion-related symptoms. After controlling for age, high school football participation, and nonfootball concussions (lifetime), diagnosed concussions in high school or college did not significantly predict concussion symptoms later in life. However, undiagnosed football head injury (range = 1-8 injuries) reported 350%-855% greater concussion-related symptoms later in life.
Undiagnosed head injuries, which are less likely to be managed by a healthcare professional, were significantly associated with concussion-related symptoms later in life. These findings suggest that proper identification and management of concussions may prevent later symptoms, but more research is needed to test this conclusion.
接触式橄榄球运动中所经历的头部创伤是一个日益严重的健康问题,但针对头部创伤暴露与前大学橄榄球运动员长期脑震荡相关症状之间的关联,所开展的研究十分有限。
我们调查了 275 名前大学橄榄球运动员,他们在比赛结束至少 10 年后,以确定头部创伤暴露与晚年的脑震荡相关症状之间的关联。受访者提供了有关其青年、高中和大学比赛经历、未确诊头部损伤、确诊脑震荡以及 8 种脑震荡相关症状的数据。采用泊松回归分析来检查比赛经历和报告的头部创伤与报告的症状计数之间的关联,显著性设置为 P≤0.05。
很少有参与者报告在大学时被诊断出脑震荡(17.5%),但很大一部分人报告了未被诊断出的与橄榄球相关的头部损伤(68.8%),这可能导致了脑震荡。少数参与者(40.7%)报告了脑震荡相关症状。在控制年龄、高中橄榄球参与度和非橄榄球脑震荡(终生)后,高中或大学时被诊断出的脑震荡并不显著预示着晚年的脑震荡症状。然而,未被诊断出的橄榄球头部损伤(范围为 1-8 次损伤)报告称晚年的脑震荡相关症状增加了 350%-855%。
未被诊断出的头部损伤,不太可能由医疗保健专业人员进行管理,与晚年的脑震荡相关症状显著相关。这些发现表明,适当识别和管理脑震荡可能预防后期症状,但需要更多的研究来验证这一结论。