Nihashi H, Yoshida M
Department of Neurology, Jichi Medical School, Tochigi, Japan.
No To Shinkei. 1988 Mar;40(3):261-6.
Whether the basal ganglia have a cognitive function or not is a worldwide dispute. We have examined 13 parkinsonian patients and 12 age-matched non-parkinsonian controls using the Modified Wisconsin Card Sorting Test (MCST). All 12 controls could achieve all 6 sets of categories which were successively changed. On the other hand, in the parkinsonians, 9 patients could achieve all 6 sets, but 4 patients could do only 4 to 0 sets. The difference between the two groups was statistically significant. These 4 patients who showed poor achievement on MCST had tendency showing higher percentage of perseverative errors. Taking the proportion of perseverative error (PE) to total error (TE) revealed that the parkinsonian group had a peak ranged from 55% to 65% which meant higher occurrence of perseverative errors. When the 4 parkinsonians whose proportion of PE/TE on MCST was over 55% were excluded, a comparison of the parkinsonians with the controls showed no significant difference statistically in both groups. There were no clinical differences based upon Yahr's classification between the 4 parkinsonians with poor MCST score and those with the normal score. Among these parkinsonians whose proportion of PE/TE ranged from 55% to 65%, 3 cases showed apparent frontal lobe signs and 3 mild dementia on Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Adults. Two patients with chorea-acanthocytosis and showing a marked atrophy of the caudate nucleus were also examined. They showed excellent results on MCST.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
基底神经节是否具有认知功能在全球范围内存在争议。我们使用改良威斯康星卡片分类测验(MCST)对13例帕金森病患者和12例年龄匹配的非帕金森病对照者进行了检查。所有12名对照者都能完成相继改变的全部6组分类。另一方面,在帕金森病患者中,9例患者能完成所有6组分类,但4例患者只能完成4至0组分类。两组之间的差异具有统计学意义。这4例在MCST上表现不佳的患者有持续性错误百分比更高的倾向。以持续性错误(PE)占总错误(TE)的比例显示,帕金森病组的峰值在55%至65%之间,这意味着持续性错误的发生率更高。当排除MCST上PE/TE比例超过55%的4例帕金森病患者后,帕金森病患者与对照者的比较在两组中均无统计学显著差异。MCST评分低的4例帕金森病患者与评分正常的患者在雅尔分类上没有临床差异。在这些PE/TE比例在55%至65%之间的帕金森病患者中,3例在成人韦氏智力量表上表现出明显的额叶体征,3例表现为轻度痴呆。还检查了2例患有舞蹈病性棘红细胞增多症且尾状核明显萎缩的患者。他们在MCST上表现出色。(摘要截取自250字)