Department of Health Promotion, Norwegian Institute of Public Health, Bergen, Norway.
Department of Work, Section for Children, Families and Disabled, Social Services and Housing, City of Bergen, Norway.
BMC Psychol. 2021 May 13;9(1):78. doi: 10.1186/s40359-021-00582-x.
During the last decade, social media has permeated most parts of society. Adolescents are particularly active users of social media, and their use has been suggested as a contributing factor to mental health issues in this group. Quantitative studies have found associations between the frequency and/or duration of social media use and more mental health issues. However, most studies are cross-sectional and the identified associations are weak and of questionable practical significance. The aim of this study was to investigate adolescents' lived experiences of using social media, focusing on both negative and positive aspects, using a qualitative approach. Qualitative research enables in-depth explorations of the experiences of individuals, nuance quantitative findings, and offer the perspective of adolescents into policies regarding social media use.
Experiences and perspectives of 27 adolescents from two senior high schools in Norway were gathered using focus group interviews (mean age 16.8, range 15-18). The data were analysed using thematic analysis.
According to the participants, social media use catalyse changes to how people communicate and relate to each other (theme 1). Some changes were positive, in terms of facilitating social connectedness, while others were negative, such as people behaving worse than in face-to-face interactions. Further, social media use affected the participants at the individual level (theme 2); positively in terms of a sense of belonging and social support, and negatively in terms of perceived stress, body pressure, and displacing other activities such as sleep and homework. The motivations for using, or not using, social media were multifaceted (theme 3), reflecting the positive and negative aspects of social media in terms of interpersonal and personal consequences.
Social media was described as an important part of the participants' everyday life, with both a positive and negative impact on their mental health and well-being. Considering the compelling nature of social media and adolescents' relatively limited self-regulatory capacities, efforts to modify social media use should avoid relying on self-regulation, while also recognizing the importance of social media as an arena for peer interaction.
在过去的十年中,社交媒体已经渗透到社会的大部分领域。青少年是社交媒体的特别活跃用户,他们的使用被认为是导致该群体心理健康问题的一个因素。定量研究发现,社交媒体使用的频率和/或时长与更多的心理健康问题之间存在关联。然而,大多数研究都是横断面研究,所确定的关联较弱,且实际意义值得怀疑。本研究旨在采用定性方法调查青少年使用社交媒体的体验,重点关注消极和积极两个方面。定性研究能够深入探索个体的体验、细微差别定量研究结果,并提供青少年对社交媒体使用政策的看法。
使用焦点小组访谈(平均年龄 16.8 岁,范围 15-18 岁)收集了来自挪威两所高中的 27 名青少年的经验和观点。使用主题分析对数据进行分析。
根据参与者的说法,社交媒体的使用促进了人们沟通和相互关系的变化(主题 1)。一些变化是积极的,有助于促进社交联系,而另一些变化则是消极的,例如人们在面对面互动中表现得更差。此外,社交媒体的使用对参与者个人层面产生影响(主题 2);在归属感和社会支持方面是积极的,而在感知压力、身体压力和取代其他活动(如睡眠和家庭作业)方面是消极的。使用或不使用社交媒体的动机是多方面的(主题 3),反映了社交媒体在人际关系和个人方面的积极和消极影响。
社交媒体被描述为参与者日常生活的重要组成部分,对他们的心理健康和幸福感既有积极影响,也有消极影响。考虑到社交媒体的强制性和青少年相对有限的自我调节能力,改变社交媒体使用的努力应避免依赖自我调节,同时认识到社交媒体作为同伴互动场所的重要性。