Centre for Biomedical Ethics, Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, National University of Singapore, Singapore
Centre for Biomedical Ethics, Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, National University of Singapore, Singapore.
J Med Ethics. 2022 Sep;48(9):611-615. doi: 10.1136/medethics-2020-106958. Epub 2021 May 14.
The success of digital COVID-19 contact tracing requires a strategy that successfully addresses the digital divide-inequitable access to technology such as smartphones. Lack of access both undermines the degree of social benefit achieved by the use of tracing apps, and exacerbates existing social and health inequities because those who lack access are likely to already be disadvantaged. Recently, Singapore has introduced portable tracing wearables (with the same functionality as a contact tracing app) to address the equity gap and promote public health. We argue that governments have an ethical obligation to ensure fair access to the protective benefits of contract tracing during the pandemic and that wearables are an effective way of addressing some important equity issues. The most contentious issues about contact tracing apps have been the potential infringements of privacy and individual liberty, especially where the use of apps or other technology (such as wearables or QR codes) is required for access to certain spaces. Here we argue that wearables, as opposed to apps alone, will make a digital contact tracing mandate more practical and explain some conditions under which such a mandate would be justified. We focus on Singapore as a case study that has recently deployed contact tracing wearables nationally, but also reference debate about wearables in Australia and New Zealand. Our analysis will be relevant to counties trialling similar portable tracing wearables.
数字化 COVID-19 接触者追踪的成功需要一个策略,该策略需要成功解决数字鸿沟问题,即无法平等获得智能手机等技术。缺乏获取途径不仅会降低追踪应用程序所带来的社会效益程度,还会加剧现有的社会和健康不平等问题,因为那些无法获得技术的人可能已经处于劣势地位。最近,新加坡推出了便携式追踪可穿戴设备(具有与接触者追踪应用程序相同的功能),以解决公平性差距问题并促进公共卫生。我们认为,政府有道德义务确保在大流行期间公平地获得接触者追踪的保护效益,而可穿戴设备是解决一些重要公平问题的有效方法。接触者追踪应用程序最具争议的问题是对隐私和个人自由的潜在侵犯,尤其是在某些场所需要使用应用程序或其他技术(如可穿戴设备或 QR 码)才能进入时。在这里,我们认为,与单独使用应用程序相比,可穿戴设备将使数字接触者追踪命令更加实用,并解释了在某些情况下这种命令是合理的。我们以新加坡作为案例研究,该国最近在全国范围内部署了接触者追踪可穿戴设备,但也参考了澳大利亚和新西兰关于可穿戴设备的辩论。我们的分析将与正在试用类似便携式追踪可穿戴设备的国家有关。